07 mars 2011

Contra-contrarianism (IFFR) 3

This is supposedly an international panel, set in Rotterdam (Netherlands), and Adrian Martin (Australian), expert on world film criticism history, and his American colleagues, could only namedrop American names as referential figures (either as positive or negative examples) : Armond White, Roger Ebert, Manny Farber, Pauline Kael, John Simon, Stanley Cavell, Jonathan Rosenbaum... So that's all there is to Worldwide Film Culture (to them!) for the past 50 years. They think that in a festival like Rotterdam, the Film Discourse ought to be exclusively about the American writers... (that proves a partial understanding of the weight of American contributions to Film literature!) At least Cristina Nord mentions Raymond Bellour (French) and a book on Alain Resnais.
If you talk to an all-American audience (captive and insular) you might entertain the belief that American culture is the center of the world... but don't expect a foreign audience to buy it. When you hold such a panel in an international festival, you should try, at least out of curtsy, if not out of admiration, to vary the origin of your references to show you care for the rest of the world. 
So can you tell me now if the culture delimited by the English language is a comfort zone? This is something that worries me a lot more than the existence of a few contrarian-mavericks within film discourse. To each his own priorities... (see English Fail)

Adrian Martin : "Farber who was a painter as well as a film critic, he basically approached all films with the same eye [..] And for him there was no difference. [..] He never said 'oh this is a low-brow Hollywood film and now we're looking at a severe minimalist whatever film'. He just talked about them in the same sentence, literaly."
I think that film criticism is using intertextuality for quite some time now. Filmmakers do it, scholars do it, insightful critics do it, bad reviewers do it, even the mainstream audience is doing it now. So what's the big deal?  
Are you encouraging Robert Koehler to namedrop "Adam Sandler" in the middle of a review of Tarr Béla's Turin Horse? Does it bring anything insightful to the conversation?  That's the kind of syncretic equivalence  used as an excuse by the bad reviewers to turn film criticism into stream of consciousness. Textbook Cultural Studies.
There is no problem using trans-genre references, when you have a solid point... but it looks stupid if you namedrop pop culture icons just to look cool. Would it occur to any painting critic to mention the name "Snoopy" in an analysis of Van Gogh's Les Tournesols? Nothing prohibits it, but is it PERTINENT? This is trash criticism, if "criticism" it is.

Adrian Martin: "It's been 10-15 years now, critics like most of us here, and some of you here. We've been fighting like hell all these years for these films [Pedro Costa, Lav Diaz, Tarr Béla...] to be recognized, to be seen, to make a  noise about these films. To the point when Apichatpong won the prize in Cannes, it was like our victory, like our birthday, it was like : 'WE WON! THE GUY, HE GOT THE PRIZE, AND HE GOT THE PRIZE BECAUSE OF US! WE WROTE HIM INTO EXISTENCE! WE YELLED ENOUGH, WE SCREAMED ENOUGH, WE WERE AGITATED ENOUGH, THAT SOMEBODY FINALLY, A BUNCH OF PEOPLE ON A JURY KNEW THAT THEY HAD TO GIVE THAT PRIZE TO APICHATPONG CAUSE HE'S GREAT.'"
Self-quote [EDIT: see correction here], again, from his Uncle Boonmee review (Sight and Sound, Dec 2010, long after Cannes 2010!) A review where he says Wong Kar-wai, Haneke [EDIT: Tsai Ming-liang]... are overrated and done for. Maybe that's his idea of baroque references across cinema genres in film writing : use the excuse to review one film to bash other filmmakers you dislike on the side.
A round of applause to Adrian Martin without whom Cannes wouldn't know about Apichatpong!!!
So the fact that Mysterious Object at Noon was selected in Vancouver 2000, that Blissfully Yours was selected in Cannes 2002 (and won the Un Certain Regard award!), that The Adventure of the Iron Pussy was selected in Berlinale 2003, that Tropical Malady was selected in Cannes 2004 (and won the Jury prize!), that Syndromes and a century was selected in Venice 2006, that Uncle Boonmee was selected in Cannes 2010 (before Adrian got a chance to write about it)... none of that shows that festivals were aware of Apichatpong's talent before 2010?
I'm very concerned that he's no longer on Americanized-firstname terms, him and "Joe"... I hope they aren't cross or anything.
I wish I could read Adrian's hypothetical articles on Apichatpong, Costa, Diaz, Tarr... He never notified me of any of them to help complete the Unspoken Cinema database. I wish I could find Cristina Nord's celebration of Lav Diaz too. 

Adrian Martin : "But there is a whole kickback now because of this position and we get all the Roger Ebert of the world saying : 'Oh, the emperor's new clothes, Apichatpong, Kiarostami this is not the great old days of Ingmar Bergman. Something is lost now in modern cinema, the heart, the soul, the human nature, where is it?' And this is the point where we've got to do some new work. It's not enough to say 'hey you've got to pay attention to Apichatpong'.
Yeah, and to the anti-slow cinema last year, he refused to take side, and published in Filmkrant (July 2010) that everyone should calm down. And now he pretends he was on the frontline.
"New work"? Really? What then? Please explain more. You're not implying that your strictly journalistic review of Boonmee was that "new work" you're talking about, right? It wouldn't occur to me to compare Apichatpong's Contemporary Art experiments to the worst period of urbanisation in human history : post-WW2 reconstruction of concrete blocks and sprawling suburbia... Lyotard or not.

Adrian Martin : "The newspaper is truly a dying form. I believe this. And particularly Arts coverage. That is not the main forum. [..] But newspapers have never been friendly to serious film criticism. They're just an extension of the movie industry."
That's why his online journal, Rouge (where most of the articles are his) didn't publish anything in 2 years. That's why he promised since 2006 and never made an online archive site for all his articles... That's how much he believes in the internet (the instantaneousness of internet). I believe what I see. I'm not moved whatsoever by political pandering.
Let's see Rouge's records (2003-2009, 13 issues) on contemporary cinema (from the names cited on the panel) :
  • Pedro Costa = 2 articles
  • Abbas Kiarostami = 2 
  • Apichatpong Weerasethakul = 0
  • Lav Diaz = 0
  • Tarr Béla = 0
  • Lisandro Alonso = 0
  • Lucrecia Martel = 0
"Fighting like hell for these films" he said. I wouldn't call that an oversaturated coverage of these auteurs... yet.
I personally do not consider it revolutionary, let alone "contemporary", to publish books today, in the XXIst century, on Hitchcock, Lang, Keaton, Rossellini, Tourneur, Blake Edwards, Lewis, De Palma, Mad Max... as if these had been "overlooked" by anterior Film Literature. There is a kind of comfort zone indulgence in sticking with the tried and true "masters" whose battles for recognition have been fought and won before you were born! It requires a lot more work to defend TODAY's filmmakers, who lack book recognition, than to bash "festival films" from the comfort of your press-screening armchair where you just wait for things to come to you effortlessly on a silver platter. I think there is even a bit of douchebaggery in that attitude, hypo-critical douchebaggery.

Adrian Martin : "It's the internet where the interesting kind of publishing is happening. Not just individuals, but also groups... You [Fujiwara] mentioned the Cahiers collective group - which is a little bit fascistic the way they do that - Groups of like-minded critics who got to pool their interests and put together their sensibility, their interest in a certain kind of cinema. That's where the future is. It's groups on the internet. It's not individuals in newspapers anymore."     
"Fascist"? If he knew the meaning of this word he wouldn't use it lightly for flare. It's not funny, you're not on Facebook, you're on "TV" at Rotterdam!
And I prefer Cahiers' praxis to the cheerleaders clique. They try to work as a team to show a united front to the readers, and focus their collective efforts on the kind of cinema they defined is most needing their support. When you read Cahiers, you know there is a solid concerted editorial line behind it. Like it or not (and I don't like Delorme's mandate) they defend a certain conception of cinema, like they always did since the Cahiers jaunes, albeit the changing editors changes the line along the way when appropriate. It's a much better method, than to let writers pick random movies without any long-term group coherence.
In every newspaper, articles are chosen by the editor anyway, who decides if it fits their marketing strategy all the same. Or writers are hired based on their identified taste, which defines the same kind of editorial control...

Groups, internet, comfort zone... a whole new bag of worms. Where to start? The idea is interesting in itself, but the application never accomplished anything out of the ordinary, as far as I could witness. Internet SHOULD be the most appropriate place for unlimited collective incentive, and it's not. Internet groups, and especially on Facebook or Twitter do exactly what Adrian Martin opposed earlier : obsessive compulsion of niche interests. Isolationism, self-confirmation, unilateral authority, averse to peer criticism... 

Neil Young : "One of the job of a film critic is to keep film festivals honest, and to really keep an eye on festival programming. Because I think that if festivals show consistently interest in good films [..] Too many festivals get away with showing films that aren't to the level you'd want them to be at. [..] We gotta be tough friends of film festivals. We gotta call it as we see it."
Well, mister critic feels all snobbish and picky. Somehow I don't think a guy whose high standards are Dude, Where's My Car? or Foxes, should be entrusted with an International Festival programing.
Unfortunately, whatever is selected in festivals rarely meets a consensual approval by the film critic community, or the festival audience. And most importantly, they seldom get picked up for distribution in your country, even the critically-acclaimed ones! 
So, you need to realise there are two separate worlds out there. The professional circuit and the public circuit.   If the commercial distribution system doesn't SHOW the best festival films to a public, and that all you write about in the press are titles from the weekly batch the industry has selected as fit for commercialisation... I see no point in festivals making an effort to please critics. If you want to deserve a right to quality control in festival programming, you will need to prove you do your part of the job, downstream, between the audience and the distributors! 

Chris Fujiwara : "If somebody who is supposed to be a film critics is worried about how can I improve the festival, how can I help the audience... [..] it's probably gonna be to the detriment of their writing as a film critic. Cause the film critic is really doing something else in my opinion. To put everything out of his/her mind, except the film and perhaps some relevant things about its context."   
Whaaaaaaa? This guy confuses everything! 

Reviewing a film, which is what they do in the weekly press that follows the commercial distribution, means giving the spotlight to that particular film, and not wasting space on other unrelated topics, like a recount of what happened to you in the theatre, or last week, or some political rant, or digressing on another film. Because this is unfair to the film in question, which deserves your full attention. 
But this isn't the exemplary form of film criticism. It's one formated by the industry of cinema who wants publicity, and by the newspaper routine, who fills the entertainment pages. 
Now if you talk about The Film Critic, how this practice should be ideally... you need to be more ambitious and aim higher. There are better things to do in film criticism than to advertise whatever titles finally come out in a theatre near you... however well you write about them. 
Putting people in theatre seats, selling admissions, is a materialist consideration, that mainly concerns exhibitors, distributors and producers. Everyone else is paid all the same, whether the film bombs or not. 
To give an idea of the best way to produce film criticism, you don't need to refer to the assembly line job of a reviewer! In this case, "putting everything out of the mind" is total bullshit. Think outside the prefab mold the movie industry has prepared for you. Film critics are NOT the film press. 
It is possible to write about cinema outside of the queued distribution, assembling several films together in the same article, playing on comparisons, or not talking about the film-object at all, but about sub-elements : images, landscapes, gestures,    situations, plot structures, aesthetic ideologies, character traits, background inspiration, influences... or about trends, aesthetic forms, technique evolutions...

Adrian Martin : "And for me the way forward is like Chris said : good writing, but good writing in a new mode. Which is the mode that the internet allows. Words and images. Words and moving images. Words and sounds and music. Trying to get all the resources of the internet to create new ways of speaking about film." 
First, he concurs with Fujiwara's mindless statement, without questioning it at all. They just have to mention "good writing" and they can immediately read eachother's mind!
Second, I'd like to see Adrian Martin's own multimedia attempts he proposes here. He always cites his one all-photos issue of Rouge, years ago. But if it's only photo, it's not multimedia. And I have no idea why my article he published there in 2009 was stripped of most of the photos I illustrated it with. So much for caring about mixed-media! 
Thumbing up the movie The Social Network on Facebook is herd mentality or out of the comfort zone?
Only 200-400 views for the videos of this panel on YouTube? Apparently his 700 Facebook "friends" are not attentive followers???

Adrian Martin : "One thing I truly believe is that real critics and real cinephiles should have absolutely no track with common sense"
I hope they won't take back his tenure when they hear about this anti-intellectual statement... Was it the guy who defined ethics by the word "intuition" and now declares "common sense" is not part of his vocabulary?
Note that he's not afraid to insist "truly", "absolutely", leaving "no" room for nuance.

I don't have a doctorate in epistemology but I will assume he meant "conventional wisdom" or "crowd-wisdom". Contrarians oppose conventional wisdom while still using common sense. Only illuminated gurus discard common sense, to install a new fallacious logic. If we don't have a common sense basis to share with the audience/readers, writers would have to explain every word they use, demonstrate every concept they mention... I doubt you're prepared to walk that high-wire without safety net, where you invent into existence the next meter of wire that will support your weight. Until you become a genius, stick to the tried and true concepts developed by the history of Mankind. 
Actually, "common sense" is insufficient for the discourse of a film critic, of course. But if a critical analysis superceeds "common sense" (with technical knowledge, cultural erudition, aesthetic history, rational judgment...), it does NOT contradict it. I see no reason why critics should NEVER approach common sense... It's just a random posture, without any particular advantages, and evidently a lot of disavantages.
Again, I think there is a confusion between the role of a critic and one of an artist. The latter could perfectly decide to avoid making sense (like Surrealists did), while producing an interesting body of work, which could very well be articulated by sensical critics. But critics rebeling against rationality are coping out of reality, and failing the humility of their mission.


What if these guys were teaching at the university? Oh wait, they do. Poor students inheriting the confusion of their professors... This won't help the future generations in film culture. Anybody can become a film teacher apparently... no need to have a clue or to have didactic skills. Pedagogy is another dying English word.
What's more embarassing? An underexposed blogger "making a name for himself" out of a contrarian posture (OMG stealing fame from the institutional celebrities!) or an institutional celebrity "making a name for herself" educating film students with fallacies? I know the answer. Do you?


02 mars 2011

Contra-contrarianism (IFFR) 2

Is there such a thing as critical courage in this world anymore? You can't sell weapons and ammunitions to both sides of a war, and sit back in your neutral seat, enjoying your stable job of weekly synopsiser. That's the difference between the weekly reviewers who are just there to watch movies for free (mindless cog without accountability in the system), and the film critics who consider their choices, their battles, their involvements have a certain responsibility in the direction this industry goes, what it allows and what it disallows.
There are intelligent ways to deal with the Oscars. Don't tell me you MUST cover the ceremony if you want to keep your platform of expression... because it means that job you hold on to so dearly is corrupt. Think outside the box! Sometimes you have to realize that the way the industry wants you to work is NOT the only possible way, that there are alternate channels of communication, and when there aren't, it is your RESPONSIBILITY to create them.
If you consider yourself a more serious film critic than the reviewers who report on the event, leave the easy job to the untalented, and show you can put your Lav Diaz skills to use on the state of the industry epitomized by the Oscars. Especially when you're sitting on a panel organised by "Filmkrant's SLOW CRITICISM", maybe you should experiment with slow coverage of the MPAA's ego-fest... with a tangential angle and outside of the timely window of their promotional campaign.
A critic with self-respect does not HAVE to stay on the Hollywood rail-tracks.

How many people in the room believe they are actively resisting the appeal of their own comfort zone? It's well and dandy to say it, to publicize the idea, but leading the way by example would be even better.
I'm not sure people who organize a panel entitled "out of the comfort zone" truly welcome the criticism of their lectures as they spent most of time trying to make the critical scrutiny part of film writing sound "conformist"...


Chris Fujiwara : "Reject the audience. Blame the audience [Manny Farber]. [..] I think the critic should oppose something. And I think what the critic should oppose these days is the audience. The audience needs to be opposed."
WTF? As much as I would enjoy to watch this happen (critics stopping to pander to their readership, stopping to indulge the emotional dependency of the regular movie-goers)... I have no idea what this odd incitation is going to accomplish. I'm never this radical myself. Maybe he took a page from Albert Serra's book...
Before all, define this generic "audience" (anybody? everybody? no matter their taste and reaction to the film?), define the level this opposition will be applied to (the box office choice? their taste? their engagement? their appropriation? their interpretation? their culture?). 
So if you're opposing the audience systematically, before knowing what they watch, what they think... you're being contrarian, the perverse kind. Without any specifics, this gratuitous radicalization yields little promise to improve the level of film discourse. This pseudo-provocative advice is pointless. I'm pretty sure Farber wasn't this vague and all-encompassing, without specific examples. 
The critical thinking opposition, if you call film criticism's responsibility that, is not directed at the consumers themselves, but at the resulting culture. The admissions are like ballots in an election, you don't randomly oppose voters... This is a poll of their needs and demands. You would want to oppose the conjuncture that influences their choice.

Within the "Out of the Comfort Zone" framework, maybe he meant to oppose the audience that goes to "Comfort Movies". That's different. The mainstream audience is shallow, self-indulgent, safe, conservative and impatient. Yes. That is the fact we can gather from the scores at the box office, and the blockbusters they support. We may oppose reality, but the function of a critic goes beyond a simple constatation.
The function of film criticism is not to make the audience feel guilty, it's to propose a higher cultural environment that maintains quality control at the production end as well as the offering end. Educate the audience. Expose the audience to a more varied choice. Organize cross-cultural exchanges.

Should critics "oppose something"? This is the statement I would most likely accept here. But not in reference to the audience. Like they briefly mentioned before all jumped on the "skeptical of skepticism" bandwagon, being contrarian means keeping a critical distance with received ideas, whether they come from the filmmakers or from the culture that inspired them. So unlike the audience who grants unconditional trust to the film experience, the film critic shall question the narrative process in the film and its implications every step of the way. Film critics shall oppose the film, meaning they always need to be suspicious, inquisitive, analytical, even if their final review will only present a vulgarized, yet educated, opinion (without the theoretical /aesthetic investigation/demonstration).
This is how we should understand this relation between the film, the audience, and the critic.

Chris Fujiwara : "Why is it so important that YOU should be entertained, instructed, sent a message to, stimulated. Or me. What is so important about YOU that the film should do this for you? We have to reverse this implied hierarchy and we have to go to the film, and do what the film wants us to do."
Last year, he wrote (badly) about ethics, and said exactly the contrary... He said that the reader was part of the urgent responsibilities of the critic, and that Myself (the writer, one audience member in particular) was the first "ethical urgency". Nice flip-flop! I guess he is learning.
Of course what this above quote says is right. I just wish he meant it. And he is wrong about attributing this moral discipline to the everyday spectator... this intellectual rigor only applies to the exceptional viewer who intends to comment and judge a film : the film critic. There is no reason to deprive the entire movie going population of the wonders of identification and suspension of disbelief. They knowingly, willingly abandon themselves to the manipulative narrative put in place by the storyteller (be it a commercial product or a masterpiece, the primal purpose of a movie, like a book, is to capture an audience and transport it). This is the whole point of buying entertainment. And THEY have the right to react to the film subjectively, selfishly, unfairly.
Regular spectators do what the film wants them to do, they wonder "whodunnit?" because the story requires suspense, they believe images of a flashback even if it is the lie of a character, they feel tensed when the music orders them to, they jump when a blast surprises them... This is being a slave of the narrative put in place on purpose by the film. And they do it naturally. 
The position of a film critic is slightly different. This is why a film critic is NOT a random spectator, therefore cannot claim the self-indulgent prerogatives reserved to the general audience. The discourse of a critic shouldn't be self-concerned, or else his voice does not deserve to elevate his personal opinion above the noise of the mass. 
If you're saying this to film students, OK. But make sure you're not suggesting every spectator must turn into a film critic to watch cinema. Because it's bullshit. In fact, most filmmakers hate critics, and prefer the innocence and candor of the regular audience.

"Going towards the film" means something else entirely. It means not being a self-centric consumer who demands the film to deliver our expectations. That is entertainment. What art in cinema is, can only come from the road map the auteur designed, and we are invited to visit HIS world, whether we like it or not. We make the humble choice to give the artist a chance and let him do whatever he has decided to do. We watch a film, like we visit a museum, to learn what the artist wants to say, not to find the confirmation of our own preconceptions about what his art might or should be. Once you've let the artist deploy the fullness of his vision, the way he meant it, the critic steps in and criticize the wonders and shortcomings of the film's vision (not dictated by the critic's own personal taste).

Chris Fujiwara : "I want the viewer to have less agency, and less control. I want to viewer to sit and watch the fucking film, in the dark, in a theatre, and not fuck around. I believe in this old-school belief of the passive spectator. Someone who has to seat through the film as an ordeal. Even as a torture."
Wow, what a pathetic view of cinema... is he allergic to nuance? No need to be so radical and make "challenging cinema" sound like "torture". If you're an idiot who asks for easy entertainment, maybe it's torture to you. But there are people who seek unsettling artworks opening the mind, for the intellectual challenge it promises. There are experiences in your life that are enlightening, even if you never asked for it, even if it doesn't fit your preferences, even if it shakes your belief. Leaving your comfort zone shall not be torture!
To be a humble guest invited to receive a filmic object? Yes. To sit until the film closes? Yes. To be passive? No. To consider a challenging work an ordeal? No. To torture yourself to watch films you hate? No.
And then he cites Rivette... WTF? Now we understand why he wanted to randomly "oppose the audience". A filmmaker may choose to torture his audience, playfully, or perversely. And the audience will play along, or accept the challenge willingly.
But this is a tacit contract between an artist and an audience. Not between a critic and his/her readers, or between a critic a filmmaker's audience. They relate on different levels and for different purposes.

Chris Fujiwara : "We should give the audience the tools to quit their jobs so they can devote their life to cinema."
It's with sentences like these you can tell he has no clue what he's talking about. Not even as a contorted metaphor does this have any poetical moral. For once, someone (Neil Young) stands up and opposes his silly anecdote with the common sense he lacks.

Like in the case of the Rivette quote, he mixes up the distinct societal roles of filmmaker, critic and audience. 
That a filmmaker leaves everything behind to dedicate his/her life to the development of a cinematographic vision makes sense, not only that but it's noble and even recommanded. Some of the best films have been made that way, thanks to the sacrifice of few people who believed in the final result despite the economical bankruptcy, the social alienation and the intellectual disapproval. There is a sense of mystical calling, devotion, radical commitment in the pursuit of an artistic career at the highest level. Not for a critic or a spectator.
That a critic quits his/her commercial employers that prevents the publication of anything insightful, seems to be self-evident, unless authoring poster quotes doesn't keep you awake at night... If you can't do your job, by staying in this job, why try to complacently justify yourself? Either you are exercizing critical thinking or you don't, there is no middle where you are honest on tuesdays and you lie the rest of the week.
That a spectator quits a job in order to dedicate more time to cinema is absurd. When the Young Turks did this, to squatt La Cinémathèque, they intended to become critics first, and then filmmakers. It works for any career, you start to obsess with a certain discipline to become an expert and leave the life of civilian amateur to go professional. 
But in the filmmaker-audience relationship, there is no ambition to turn all spectators into filmmakers, let alone compulsive viewers. And the raison d'être of a critic is NOT to turn readers into addicts. Unless you plan to found an occult sect... You're out of your mind. You're mistaking Art with Religion.
Even in an ideal world, I can not conceive the necessity for the generalisation of this individual case. No masterpiece, of the greatest arts, calls for such a devout following. Not even Mozart, Michelangelo, Shakespeare or Orson Welles.

If you hop on a soapbox to make public declarations, in the name of "film criticism" (in the hope to fix film culture!), you can't just say whatever bullshit goes through your head... it would be embarassing at a dinner with friends, it is insulting at an international film festival. Seeing film culture so misrepresented drives me mad!

Chris Fujiwara : "The tools that critics can give to readers and viewers is just the text, good writing on film, we don't have to be ambitious in a theoretical way, you know, the high-faluting concepts that we are devoted to. [..] [Q: How to maintain your trust with the readers?] By writing as well as you can, being as interesting as you can. And constructing interesting ways to view films and putting it on paper. And if people like that, then that's good."
Wow. So your advice to be good at your job is to write good writing. Thanks for the nondescript adjective and the tautological definition of "being good at what you do". Thank you so much for revealing that GOOD writing is better for film culture than BAD writing... who would have thought? Define "good"! And then get into details and how-to.  (see Good critic, bad critic) 

Neil Young : "There is always someone worse off than you. Watching starving peasants, or people in terrible dire straits, you leave the cinema and you think ' Well maybe things aren't so bad' In a way that's confirming you in your comfort zone"
Turning the argument on its head. So according to his fallacious logic, watching a story "out of your comfort zone" (because it is worse than your own situation) is what keeps you in YOUR comfort zone. So there is no possible way out of it. According to him, even the exposition to alterity reinforces your conformism. I feel like I'm listening to doublethink from Orwell's Nineteen Eighty-Four. What has a chance to extract you from your comfort zone then??? Are you trying to dissuade any attempt, and comfort people in thinking that escaping our own comfort zone is a futile endeavour anyway?  (see: Seeds for wider diversity in American Culture?)
Let's parse this with a little more intellectual honesty. The proverbial "Comfort Zone" depends on two factors. The active participation of the person and the passive context that sustains it. If spectators do all they can to leave the comfort zone, but cannot find any film providing an alternative vision, then filmmakers are to blame. If the choices are limited to a selection of safe and conformist films, then the system is to blame. If filmmakers go out of their way and film alterity, they did their part of the job. If the person still refuses to open up when given the choice, they are victim of their own apathy. Neither the artists nor the system are responsible for the perpetuation of this state of isolationism if spectators build a wall around their self-indulgent ego. Let's be clear about that before extending the "comfort zone" boundaries ad infinitum... That's why defining the conditions of a "comfort zone" prior to the debate was obligatory.



Related read:

Serge Gainsbourg

28 février 2011

Contra-contrarianism (IFFR) 1

Filmkrant (Jan 2011) and International Film Festival of Rotterdam (30 Jan 2011) present: Out of the Comfort Zone
Do film critics have a moral responsibility to go against the grain? Or is this contrarianism a mere rhetorical tool, a querulant's toy, or an easy way to establish a name for oneself in the age of cyberjournalism? And what happens when even the most daring critics are confronted with films that bring them out of their comfort zone?
A Critics' Talk about Critics, Contrarians, Conformists and Other Provocateurs
With: Dana Linssen [NL], Adrian Martin [AU], Chris Fujiwara [USA], Cristina Nord [DE], Neil Young [UK], Gabe Klinger [USA]
Here we go again, a lecture on the "responsibilities of film criticism"...
I wish they defined what they meant by "comfort zone" in introduction, to put everyone on the same page. Cause they weren't clear what the notion of "comfort zone" or "anti-comfort zone" corresponded to. To the point that "contrarian" became equated to "conformist" by a strange twist of sophistry. Some even said they were both categorically for and categorically against, without being able to tell which exclusive position was right. After a lot of stereotypes, moderator Dana tried repeatedly to extort answers and practical suggestion from this panel, in vain. They are all full of good ideas (some don't even know what they mean), but - spoiler alert! - revealing how to get there is not for today.

High mark : the panel is international (like the host : Rotterdam festival), although despite all communicating in the English language (4 of the 6 panelists' native idiom), they didn't feel the need to address the fact that English-spoken culture might be a "comfort zone" for some, and a bit exclusionary for film criticism published in the rest of the non-English-speaking world. 
Also, the debate was filmed and uploaded online (for free)! Unlike the Ljubljana panel (if you know where to find it please leave a link)

And since they didn't manage to interact with the public in attendance, someone has got to give them some feedback. I'll show them the benefits of playing Devil's Advocate.


* * *


Adrian Martin : "Armond White... Taste is a prison..." 
Adrian Martin is mad at contrarians as if every critics on Earth acted against the dominant opinion (for the sake of disagreeing and being original?) or trapped in a niche, a "fixed religion" (Armond White IS that majoritary model apparently). And he's on a campaign to eradicate this kind of practice from film discourse... (textbook straw man fallacy!) 
First, I would hope that Armond White was not the role model brought up in a SERIOUS PANEL about SERIOUS FILM CRITICISM, he's as relevant as Roger Ebert, meaning relevant to populist appeal. Do you feel threatened by his level of discourse? OMG Armond White becomes the talk of the Rotterdam Festival!!!! I didn't even know his notoriety exceeded NYC. Why do you compare yourself to the lowest standards? Because they have the popularity? Do you enjoy beating a dead horse? Measure up to models of your stature at least for a fair game. 
Second, if you didn't pick such a lame role model, you wouldn't define one of the actual missions of a film critic, skeptical cross-examination, as uni-dimensionally as a guy who disagrees by perversion (not because there are reasons to play devil's advocate sometimes?) and a relentless activity at the exclusion of anything else (as if Adrian Martin was the only one with an ecclectic taste in the world). 
Breaking news: Contrarians are a minority, undiscriminate filmgoers are a majority. If something should be disconcerting and dealt with, it's rampant equivalence.

If you can't tell whether someone disagrees systematically without purpose, either that contrarian is doing a good job faking it, or you're not qualified to pass this judgement... Threat level to film discourse? about as high as for any hack film reviewer employed in the press, contrarian or complacent. 

Another point worth considering : within the world of mediocre film reviewing (i.e. weekly newspapers and similar online movie-guides), when contrarians are as shallow and subjective as their mainstream peers, the simple fact of them opposing majoritary taste and received ideas (for good or bad reasons, we don't care, since the result is mediocre anyway), shows a modicum of critical activity. Yes. When two equally bad reviewers are compared, the one with a contrarian approach will at least construct a form of argumentation based on disputing an analyzed position from a colleague, if not from the film's mise en scene. 

And if competent critics decide to write a skeptical paper, which is not to frown upon in and of itself, they probably have solid reasons to do so. Thus, it's not the contrarianism itself that lowers film culture, it's a-critical criticism.

You see, I don't believe that imposing ecclectic taste to incompetent reviewers, or film students, or spectators, will issue higher standards of criticism. You need to acquire critical standards first. Then you'll be able to evaluate whatever is thrown at you, any which way you so desire. But you can't invent your own hierarchies if you don't know how the ones established before you had been made. "Freestyle aesthetics" is for the erudite, not for the illiterate anarchists.

Now, I'll tell you one thing, there is something much worse than a contrarian, however bad a job (s)he does, and it's a critic who refuses DEBATE, thinking that by ignoring dissent, head stuck in the sand, all is perfect in a perfect world where everyone agrees with MY TASTE. That, is BAD CRITICISM in my books. In fact it is not criticism, it is more like panegyric. If you advocate one, you'll find faults in the other, obviously. 
So since you're bragging about only writing about films you love, and you make a point in refusing any discussion with people who don't adore the films you cherish... (Adrian Martin will recognize himself there) you're not in a good position to patronize film critics about open-mindedness and critical responsiblities! You have your own comfort zone. Leave that to critics (not cheerleaders who are trapped in their ivory towers) maybe they have a chance to make a credible argument in this direction (*IF* banning cross-examination from the praxis of film criticism could ever be taken seriously). 


Adrian Martin: "Down with Ingmar Bergman... Generation gap... blah blah blah"
Have we heard this before? Self-quote lifted from his Filmkrant column in reaction to Rosenbaum's Bergman Op-Ed. Self-indulgence or out of the comfort zone?

Adrian Martin : "For me the important thing is to constantly go back and forth between all the different sorts of culture of films"
Let me build another straw-man for you : Now you've done it! Every critic on Earth is a generalist, loving all genres equally, and knowing a bit of everything, and nothing deep of anything (because if they dig too deep in one place, they alienate themselves from knowing everything else). That's what you advocate, right? What are we gonna do with only generalists and no specialists???? This is ruining film culture! Let's blame open-mindedness now. 
It was easy to take a seemingly self-important position in "favor" of film culture and undermining it in another excess? Critical insight at the end of the day? None. Straw-men do not help to define helpful conducts. 

What is your point to shame people who opt to focus their efforts to improve the understanding of one specific area of cinema, be it elitist culture or sub-culture? What greater goal are you trying to accomplish? How could the mere existence of specialists infringe the freedom of expression of the generalists? Film culture is the sum of the contributions by specialists and generalists, by conservatives and contrarians, by journalists and scholars, by publicists and spectators...

There are people who think that escaping your comfort zone is to embrace the mercantilisation of culture made by Hollywood, let's call them "cheerleaders" cause they are the "real cinephiles" who dare to watch even crap movies. And there are people who think that to expose a counterargument to the mainstream "common wisdom" is kinda different from the self-indulgence entrenched in the guilty-pleasure filled proverbial "comfort zone", let's call them "contrarian" to discredit any trace of critical value in their skeptical intentions. 
Yeah all it takes is to redefine words, through a clever marketing campaign, to justify your own fallacies and make those who are more critical than you sound useless. I guess the dumb readers might fall for it...

Maybe it is the important thing FOR YOU, and it is certainly something we should encourage for everyone interested in it. But is it worth sacrificing skepticism in film criticism? I don't think so. No reason to oppose them, to make us pick one OR the other. They are not polar opposites, not an exclusive dichotomy.

Adrian Martin : "disregarding auteur and genre, crossing the lines of mainstream, arthouse and film festival exhibition, opening your mind to the odd, subterranean zeitgeists that always flow in, around and underneath our shared culture."
It's called Baroque, and it's hardly the highest peak in Art History. Random collage of anything and everything, mixing styles against any aesthetic coherence, disregarding balance and harmony, stuffing in the most possible elements, and above all showing off, exuberance. I'm not sure that's the stuff film culture lacks, or has been missing all these years. I'm not sure either it's the brilliant idea that will save a dying film culture crumbling under the perils of syncretic equivalence. Intertextuality is great, but it doesn't mean that ANY random crossover mix will be insightful and this is the weakness of Cultural Studies. This is the old bulimic/anorexic (false) quarrel, right?



Cristina Nord: "Being a contrarian can be staying in your own personal comfort zone, of your taste, and your likes and dislikes. And I think that's indeed a danger. It can be something that is very self-indulgent."
WTF? It's not being contrarian then, if you're not disagreeing BECAUSE it is the dominant opinion (the side your counterpoint is going to defend is dependent on what others will bring up), but because it is YOUR comfort zone to think that way (whatever others think, you already know what you're going to write). See the difference between being contrarian by principle (always against everything else no matter what) and being contrarian by coincidence (your insular taste somehow happens to be contrary to the mainstream). This distinction might sound a too subtle to some... but believe me, intentionality makes a world of difference.

Cristina Nord: "I can't do this exclusively. Like, if I only do Lav Diaz, if I only do Apichatpong Weerasethakul, if I only do Lisandro Alonso, Lucrecia Martel, films that are rarely shown in Germany, films that are not mainstream, films that not a lot of people have access to see. I have, like, to find other options as well." 
First, what unwritten rule of the Film Criticism holy book would bind you to the same limited number of auteurs for a lifetime sentence? This phobia of exclusivity is a non-issue. Are you trying to convince yourself that it's OK to review the commercial fare? Or are you just name dropping these hardcore names to justify your weekly review job? I don't get it. But thanks for sharing. 
Does it really matter who covers which specific auteur? Is there a quota to balance the Hollywood easy reviews with the more demanding effort to criticize a challenging artwork for the brains? 
All I know is that if you only review commercially released products (filtered by the industrial infrastructure) you're doing a bad job. If you only review a Lav Diaz film when it is released commercially, it's a cop out, or a sell-out to the commercial censorship I should say (because you're playing their game and they will continue to quarantine artfilms because it prevents you from writing about them). 
Personally, I see a problem when compromises don't matter anymore. Reviewing Oscars (like a million other journalists in the world!) and reviewing an underexposed film by Lav Diaz, cannot be the same undifferentiated commitment for a critic... It's not a matter of acquired taste, or defending the Great Cinema for the cultural elite against the bad mainstream cinema. It's a matter of understanding your role as a film critic within the media system that allows you to watch films, and write about them. Either you're a resistant or you're a collaborator! You can't tell your buddies you helped Lav Diaz one day and promoted the marketing machine that destroyed local cinema in The Philippines the next day. Either you care about how things got perverted, or you don't. You can't play for both teams, and then patronize the resistance for being excessively motivated by their cause... This is RIDICULOUS. Don't tell me you feel responsible for the success of art filmmakers if you consider your duty to add an umptieth Oscars coverage to the pile of self-promotion. 
Will critics ever realize that it is IMPOSSIBLE to continue to support an industry that goes against freedom of expression, diversity, education and art? 

Full series : Contra-contrarianism (IFFR) 1 - 2 - 3 - 4 - 5


Related read:

25 février 2011

GQ vs Hollywood (Harris)

The Day the Movies Died
by: Mark Harris (GQ, Février 2011)

I wonder why it's GQ that dares to tell Hollywood how it really is. What's the use of running an "independent" cinephile publication if you don't have the balls to give an honest and insightful scrutiny to the majors who suppress independent cinema... I guess GQ has bigger balls than the NYT (who bows to digital distribution and 3D barnum) or Film Comment (who is too busy sabotaging the festival circuit)... American Fatalism will never die, the American movies will. You gotta sacrifice quality when you desperately want to be #1 in quantity. And even the "film critics" (I'm hesitant to use this word in this case) are willing to play their part to make sure foreign cinema abroad, and independent cinema at home keeps the head under the water.

"It has always been disheartening when good movies flop; it gives endless comfort to those who would rather not have to try to make them and can happily take cover behind a shield labeled "The people have spoken." But it's really bad news when the industry essentially rejects a success [Christopher Nolan's Inception], when a movie that should have spawned two dozen taste-based gambles on passion projects is instead greeted as an unanswerable anomaly. That kind of thinking is why Hollywood studio filmmaking, as 2010 came to its end, was at an all-time low—by which I don't mean that there are fewer really good movies than ever before (last year had its share, and so will 2011) but that it has never been harder for an intelligent, moderately budgeted, original movie aimed at adults to get onto movie screens nationwide."
This is the reason why you must be cynical about the way movies are made in Hollywood. I can not dellude yourself in thinking the few decent blockbusters that come out of this marketing factory were made ON PURPOSE. Filmic art in Hollywood emerges in spite of the system, when it's lucky enough to infiltrate incognito all the barrages!!!
Though, when a dude in GQ charges on Hollywood to defend an half-assed blockbuster like Inception (ranked above any foreign masterpieces in the American top10 lists!) taken as an exemple of cinema's ultimate greatness... you know the American film culture is deep up its own ass.

Scott Rudin (producer of The Social Network, True Grit) : "Studios are hardwired not to bet on execution, and the terrible thing is, they're right. Because in terms of execution, most movies disappoint."
Meanwhile there are still critics who believe that the "genius of the system" is the key that produces great mise en scène in today's commercial movies... WTF?

"Top Gun landed directly in the cortexes of a generation of young moviegoers whose attention spans and narrative tastes were already being recalibrated by MTV and video games. That generation of 16-to-24-year-olds—the guys who felt the rush of Top Gun because it was custom-built to excite them—is now in its forties, exactly the age of many mid- and upper-midrange studio executives. And increasingly, it is their taste, their appetite, and the aesthetic of their late-'80s postadolescence that is shaping moviemaking. Which may be a brutally unfair generalization, but also leads to a legitimate question: Who would you rather have in charge—someone whose definition of a classic is Jaws or someone whose definition of a classic is Top Gun?"
The follow up question would be : Who would you rather have in charge of an institutional cinephile publication (i.e. Sight and Sound),  someone whose definition of a classic is Inception or someone whose definition of a classic is Citizen Kane?

"In some ways, the ascent of the marketer was inevitable: Now that would-be blockbusters often open on more than 4,000 screens, the cost of selling a movie has skyrocketed toward—and sometimes past—$40 million to $50 million per film, which is often more than the movie itself cost to make."
The problem with American businessmen, is that either a movie can be sold on 4000 screens, or it's not even worth trying. They don't know the concept of parallel circuit, or niche market, or Long Tail consumers, or slow distribution. They do extensive production, just like they do their corn, never under 9 digits a head. Someone need to tells all the wannabe producers to stop trying to be #1. Every other country in the world produces and distributes dozens/hundreds of successful and quality movies, popular or artsy, without the gazillion dollars pumped into Hollywood. So I'm pretty sure if they took a class in cost-control, they would find a niche market at appropriate size for their capability (instead of aiming at what their overestimated ambition tells them to)

"Such an unrelenting focus on the sell rather than the goods may be why so many of the dispiritingly awful movies that studios throw at us look as if they were planned from the poster backward rather than from the good idea forward. Marketers revere the idea of brands, because a brand means that somebody, somewhere, once bought the thing they're now trying to sell. [..] Sequels are brands. Remakes are brands. For a good long stretch, movie stars were considered brands; this was the era in which magazines like Premiere attempted to quantify the waxing or waning clout of actors and actresses from year to year because, to the industry, having the right star seemed to be the ultimate hedge against failure."
Hollywood is definitely run by publicists, like they are given CREATIVE POWERS. A populist melodrama is bad enough, appealing to the lowest instincts and Pavlovian conditionning of basic emotions. But there is something that makes more money than that, turning cinema into 90 minute long commercials. The biggest worry is not actual product placement (for incidental product sales), the movie has now become a tautological selling argument, self-alimenting itself, swallowing the hypnotized audience and the complacent reviewers who all love to be part of this big shiny Zeitgeist bandwagon untill they are directed to the next big thing.

"[..] can't-miss movies miss all the time. But when a movie that everyone agrees is pre-sold falls on its face, the dullness of the idea itself never gets the blame. Because the idea that familiarity might actually work against a movie, were it to take hold in Hollywood, would be so annihilating to the studio ecosystem that it would have to be rebuilt from the ground up. Give the people what they don't know they want yet is a recipe for more terror than Hollywood can accommodate."
If Hollywood was only mercantile, we could accept their business model, the economical logic of their choices... as long as the mass wants more of it. But that's not all. Hollywood is also stupid at its own game. They make BAD BAD BAD commercial products all year long, based on ultra-safe formulaic recipe. They are bad at being businessmen! They are wasteful maniacs. Because they make such indecent amount of money when they do succeed, they don't even care when they fail again and again, hoping for the magic blockbuster, like compulsive gamblers. Unfortunately they don't take risks with creative filmmakers, to discover the future infatuation of mainstream taste (like fashion designers would do for instance), no, they keep repeating the past safe recipe, copying eachothers, stealing formulae, ripping off, spining off, revamping, recycling... Frankenstein movies that only have the empty shell of what once was a "movie"!

"[..] the degree to which children's genres have colonized the entire movie industry goes beyond overkill. More often than not, these collectively infantilizing movies are breeding an audience—not to mention a generation of future filmmakers and studio executives—who will grow up believing that movies aimed at adults should be considered a peculiar and antique art. Like books. Or plays."
How I wish film writers in the specialized cinephile press were half as concerned as this guy...
Meanwhile smartasses declare that "Dude, Where's My Car?" or "Stuck on You" or "Wall-E" or "Toy Story 3" or whatever Jackie Chan does... should be on the same level as high-brow art, alongside the achievements of Kiarostami, Tarr or Lynch. That's so mature to make immaturity sound like serious cinema... Not. Grow up! It was smart to pick Hitchcock, of all Hollywood employees, within the commercial system... but today's kid's movies are nowhere near Hitchcock, Hawks, Ford or Chaplin! 

"In a way, that kind of thinking is just the terminus of a decades-long marginalization of the very notion of creative ambition by the studios. If in the 1970s making good original movies was a central goal of the men who ran the studios, by the 1980s that goal had devolved to making good original movies to release at the end of the year, for Oscar season. In the 1990s, as the boom in American independent filmmaking began, the idea of a "good" movie, as New York Times critic Manohla Dargis has pointed out, eventually became a niche that could be outsourced—first to self-made moguls like Harvey Weinstein and then to boutique divisions of the studios themselves. "There was a moment a few years ago," says Schamus, "when studios said, 'Hey, all of these specialty companies seem to be taking up all the seats in the front row at the Oscars, so if they can do it, we can do it—we'll just throw money at them!' "
THERE IS NO SUCH THING AS "AMERICAN INDEPENDENT CINEMA".
Get real already. Visit the world, get familiarized with what the word "independent" stands for outside of the USA (where words have longer objective definition).
Read what was written about the Hollywood fare back in 1931 by Philippe Soupault ! The production was already profit-driven. You would think that after walking around knee-deep into shit for the better part of a century, American Film Critics would eventually rebel and contest this mentality, support the emergence of a non-blockbuster market... That would be underestimating American Fatalism. Deep in shit, they got used to it, they love it, they wouldn't exchange their place for anything, not even foreign masterpieces!  

"[studio executives and marketers] They're philistines, foes of art, craven bottom-liners, vulgarians."
Don't worry Hollywood, you will always find smartass wannabe-critics who find cute and hip to rebel against the "overrated establishement of high-brow art". Easy to find them, they are the ones who didn't lose their job in the press! They think bashing elitist art is the most revolutionary thing they can do in this mercantile era. This is so "subversive" to love Hollywood when nobody, really nobody, gives Hollywood the attention it deserves. Really? History will remember them... not in a good way though.

"And overseas markets are becoming less predictable and more insular—Schamus points out that Japan and Italy have taken a pronounced turn away from Hollywood films and toward homegrown fare, a trend that's likely to spread around the globe. (And adult dramas play particularly poorly abroad.)"
OK. Now I stop to concur. The fact that foreign markets bend over to Hollywood in a predictible pattern is one thing. But deciding that BECAUSE they begin to buy less Hollywood crap equates to "even abroad they don't make/watch adult drama" is bullshit. Since outside of the USA we do not know how to make epic superhero blockbusters or 3D spectacles... I garanty you that dramas with actual storytelling skills, aimed at a mature audience (rather than saying "adult drama" like if it was "porn"!) is still selling pretty well, in France, in Italy, in Japan, in the UK, or pretty much anywhere else. See, if Hollywood didn't make such dumb movies... the world would probably not watch any.

"Put simply, we'd rather stay home, and movies are made for people who'd rather go out."
You're a bit presumptuous there! Do you think Hollywood is worried that the movies they make will be sold on DVD or on VOD rather than the big screen? Before the technological upgrade of TV sets to the 16/9 aspect ratio, Hollywood shot their films on 16/9 film for the TV 4/3 aspect ratio, by leaving no meaningful details or characters in the side margins. Now that 16/9 home-video settings exist, they still shoot for the 4/3 to cater to the consumers who kept their old TV. That's not what I call "making films for the big screen". When films used to be letterboxed, rather than pan-and-scan, yes films were made for the cinemascope screen; not anymore. 3D cinema is probably the only specific technique that shows Hollywood wants to make movies that are best seen on the big screen. But Hollywood already tried 3D in the 50ies, it's not a new fad.


Ball in your court so-called "thought-provocating film press"

Actually, there is an article somewhat critical of Hollywood in a recent issue of Sight and Sound (I don't remember which, February?, and they don't even have a full table of content on their website), what a shocker, they woke up from their complacent hibernation. That's a start.


Related read:

23 février 2011

Lumière (Tarr/Bergman)


A torinói ló (2011/TARR/Hongrie) bande annonce (45 sec)

* * *


Persona (1966/Bergman/Suède) premier plan (30 sec)


Voir aussi:

05 février 2011

Colbert Portrait 2011


My interpretation of Stephen Colbert annual fireplace portrait 2011 (see gallery here) The one-man allegory of American news media of the 21st century. Democracy on one hand, brainwashing on the other, and support to foreign totalitarian regimes in the back.

Related:

03 février 2011

Forgotten Obsolete English Words #5: Obituary


"Obituary is when celebrating an artist was already too late"
Jean-Luq Godard, apocryphal and posthumous citation

26 janvier 2011

Loyauté première de la pensée (Nietzsche)

"Ne jamais réprimer, ni te taire à toi-même, une objection que l'on peut faire à ta pensée. Fais-en le vœux. Cela fait partie de la loyauté première de la pensée. Tu dois chaque jour mener aussi campagne contre toi-même."
Aurore, 1881, Nietzsche

Akira Kurosawa (Tesson)



Conférence "Qui êtes-vous Akira Kurosawa?" de Charles Tesson
à la Cinémathèque Française (12 Jan 2011) 1h19'

24 janvier 2011

Independencia capitulada (éthique fallacieuse)

J'ai bien peur que nos petits mutins de la sécession Cahiers ne soient plus convaincants à propos des règles déontologiques de la profession de critique de cinéma, que ne l'étaient Jean-Michel Frodon ou Chris Fujiwara  : Critique, éthique, notes pour un manifeste (Independencia, 6 janvier 2011)

"Par un étrange effet dialectique, le conflit d’intérêts accroît le pouvoir du Journaliste en tant que personne en même temps qu'il discrédite la profession dans son ensemble."
Et oui, encore une histoire de conflit d’intérêts. Cette fois, au moins, ils ne l'oublient pas. Mais après un long historique, ils essaient tout de même d'inverser, par un étrange effet sophiste, la morale en concluant que le conflit d'intérêt est, en gros, nécessaire à l'activité critique... Étonnant, non? Comble d'immoralisme, les voilà qui terminent en faisant un peu d'auto-publicité pour la page "boutique" de leur site, qui vendra bientôt des T-shirt "Independencia". L'indépendence d'esprit capitule aux lois du capitalisme. Quelle leçon! A l'instar de la Russie soviétique et de la République Populaire de Chine, ils célèbrent en fin de compte les joies du capitalisme.

A quoi bon faire la révolution, se séparer d'un journal qui se vend à la corporation d'édition la plus offrante, fonder un nouveau hâvre de paix pour le cinéma "indépendent", affirmer une liberté de pensée... si c'est pour nous tenir aujourd'hui un discours pronant les vertues de l'asservissement capitaliste et de la complaisance a-critique? Je suis atterré. Les véritables révolutionnaires sont ceux qui s'accrochent jusqu'au bout, pas ceux qui crient fort un coup et qui se rangent dans le rang pour faire comme tout le monde, parce que bon, il faut manger, et que plus de recettes c'est mieux que moins de pognon.

"Jamais le pouvoir de certaines signatures et figures n'a été aussi grand. Jamais en revanche la critique n'a été autant discréditée auprès des spectateurs. Il suffit de discuter avec les programmateurs : Ils vous diront que plus les articles sont longs et enthousiastes, plus la queue devant les salles est courte." 
N'importe quoi. Bazin racontait déjà la même chose en 1958. Ce problème n'est pas celui de la conjoncture actuelle, ni celle de la critique de cinéma... c'est dans la nature des choses. Il s'agit de l'éternel fossé entre l'élite culturelle et la masse des consommateurs. Qu'on le veuille ou non, ce phénomène de friction entre la minorité qui se sent persécutée et la majorité qui rejettent les experts, qu'il soit réel ou fantasmatique, a toujours existé, et existera toujours. Quand bien même nous arriverions à fondre les uns dans les autres, cette nouvelle majorité consensuelle se trouvera de nouveaux ennemis plus radicaux qui revendiqueront leur opinion minoritaire. C'est une affaire de point de vue.  Ça dépend du côté de la barrière d'où l'on se place. Ca dépend du côté de la barrière où l'on croit être. L'élite des uns sera le populiste des autres.
Moraliser, gloser, solutionner cette réalité revient à se battre contre des moulins à vent.

Et puis, surtout, ça dépend des films en question, des publics considérés, de l'époque de publication, du pays concerné... Tout change selon la perspective. On ne peut pas décider de façon définitive, quels sont les perdants et quels sont les vaincqueurs, à quelle échéance, et pour combien de temps. Il suffit de regarder l'évolution des jugements de goût dans l'histoire culturelle. 

Est-ce que le journalisme de cinéma "attirent" assez de gens dans les salles? Est-ce qu'une critique "rapporte" suffisemment au producteur du film? Est-ce que un film à succès donne du "pouvoir" au critique qui dit du bien? Est-ce que le consommateur de base fait une confiance aveugle aux intellectuels qui dissèquent son spectacle? 
Franchement, on s'en fout! Ce sont des considérations purement mercantiles et narcissiques qui n'offrent que des satisfactions matérielles et éphémères. Ce n'est pas ça qui compte pour juger de la probité et la nécessité de l'exercice de la critique. 

Bien sûr que c'est mieux si un bon film rencontre le plus large public, si il gagne le plus d'argent possible pour pouvoir continuer à produire d'aussi bon films dans le futur. Mais ça ne devrait pas être le soucis principal du critique, malgré cette compromission de la discipline qui s'étale dans la presse. Les journalistes de cinéma se rêvent bonne fée toute puissante qui fait et défait les carrières selon ses goûts... et ils oublient d'être CRITIQUES.
A une critique efficace qui fait plaisir à une majorité de spectateurs, je préfère une critique honnête que personne n'écoute. Si les films ont besoin de mensonges complaisant pour faire des entrées, qu'ils aillent en chercher ailleurs. 
Un bon film n'a besoin que de visibilité. Visibilité sur les écrans, évidemment. Visibilité dans les médias pour alerter le public. Et après, si le public n'est pas au rendez-vous, c'est le problème de distributeur, ou celui de la paresse des spectateurs. Contrairement à ce que croient les producteurs, on ne peut pas forcer les gens à payer pour un truc qu'ils n'ont pas envie de voir (que les raisons soient bonnes ou mauvaises). 


Cette article commence en parlant de la position déontologique exemplaire :
"Dans le milieu du Journalisme, on évoque souvent l'exemple des grands quotidiens américains, où lorsqu'un chroniqueur connaît personnellement l'auteur d'un livre, par exemple, II demande à un collègue d'écrire à sa place. Il s'agit d'un principe idéal, et l'on peut douter qu'il soit systématiquement appliqué."
et se débrouille pour discréditer le fondement étique de cette règle pour réinstituer son antithèse :
"Il n'en va pas de même dans la critique. Celle-ci a une longue histoire de « copinages »"
Et c'est bien pour cette raison que la critique cinéma ne bénéficie pas de l'aura et la crédibilité de la critique littéraire ou du grand reportage! 
Oublions l'existence des pages glacées de la presse de cinéma glamour. Nous nous en tiendrons aux publications sérieuses de la presse spécialisée, et des grand quotidiens qui ont une certaine réputation dans les milieux cinéphiles. Comment voulez-vous qu'une presse cinéma aie la moindre crédibilité quand il est possible de lire, chaque semaine, un avis et son exact contraire, affirmé avec la plus solennelle autorité? Comment est-ce qu'un film peut être un chef d'œuvre et une merde, selon la publication que l'on consulte? Non, la presse de cinéma n'a aucune crédibilité dans le domaine de la critique d'art. 
La belle histoire de la critique cinématographique n'est pas celle des journaux dans lesquels on a pu la lire... C'est l'accumulation de beaux articles, écrits par de grands critiques, des penseurs du cinéma. Mais ce n'est pas "l'histoire des copinages" qui en garantie l'intégrité. Même dans le cas des Jeunes Turcs! Ils ont eu la chance, si l'on peut dire, d'être perspicaces et talentueux. Donc on leur pardonne les quelques erreurs de complaisance (qui pour la plupart ne mentaient pas). Leur complaisance a eu le bon goût de choisir de très grands cinéastes, qui ne déméritent pas aujourd'hui. Donc on ne peut pas leur en vouloir a posteriori. Mais il serait bien malhonnète de prétendre que n'importe qui peut afficher une complaisance sans vergogne, pour faire comme Truffaut, Godard, Rivette ou Rohmer... Quelle naïveté! Si vous tenez à imiter ces modèles, imitez leur justesse et non leur complaisance!

Le "socle prestigieux" de la Politique des Auteurs n'était point la complaisance érigée en règle, mais l'intuition de s'accoquiner avec des maîtres historiques du cinéma comme Hitchcock, Hawks, Ford ou Renoir... sans parler de la bande de la Nouvelle Vague. Ils avaient raison de s'admirer l'un l'autre, puisqu'ils ont produit parmis les films les meilleurs de l'époque. La complaisance devient problèmatique lorsque le critique met son jugement critique en berne, et encense de mauvais films à des fins de profits personnels. S'accoquiner avec de mauvais réalisateurs et leur donner une bonne note par charité ne fait pas de la complaisance une vertu.

"Le rapport entre économie du cinéma et critique est, pour ainsi dire, structurel. Et seulement en deuxième instance, idéologique."
Apparement le monde du cinéma est tout petit... On retrouve les mêmes personnes du côté de la production et de la critique, auteur de films ou journaliste de cinéma, producteur ou membre de la commission d'avance sur recette. Le problème c'est la mobilité des emplois et l'interdisciplinarité des CV. On le constate dans tous les secteurs. On ne conserve plus un seul job à vie, et les frontières entre formations se recoupent. Cela ne devient problématique que lors du cumul éventuel de casquettes. 
Il est tout à fait concevable qu'une personne débute sa carrière dans la critique, puis quitte le journalisme pour se mettre à faire des films, puis utilise son savoir faire pour produire les films des autres et enfin que son expérience dans le métier soit reconnue pour présider une commission. Sans être aussi linéaire que cela, il suffit d'éviter les cas de conflits d'intéret en se désistant si le lundi on est juge et mardi parti. 
Est-ce qu'un critique est capable de se sentir suffisemment responsable pour refuser un cachet si la pige ou la mission compromet l'intégrité de sa tâche? Un critique devrait être plus à même qu'aucun autre de déceler ces paradoxes, et faire montre de la force d'esprit pour résister à la tentation du gain à portée de main.

Evidemment, sans étique la vie serait tellement plus facile! Mais si c'est la vie facile qui vous intéresse, il faut choisir une autre voie que celle de garant des valeurs critiques. Il y a plein d'autres métiers où le conflit d'intérêt est la pierre d'angle de la réussite : publiciste, tradeur, assureur, banquier, avocat, politicien...

"L'autonomie que le mot - Indépendance » suggère ne devrait pas s'entendre dans le sens d'un isolement. L'Indépendance se réalise dans le monde objectif, constitué de rapports effectifs."
En somme, les rédacteurs d'Independencia voudraient nous faire avaler que quand il s'agit d'eux, le conflit d'intérêt c'est positif; que pour ménager cette poche "d'indépendence" dans la presse cinématographique, ce n'est pas grave si ils ne sont pas si indépendent que ça. "Independencia" c'est pour le marketing... ça les oblige pas à être intègre quand même! mdr

"Independencia a soutenu certains films de la « marge ». Deux exemples. Commissariat d'Ilan Klipper et Virgil Vernier, et De son appartement de Jean-Claude Rousseau. Deux débats étaient prévus, en notre présence, un à Tremblay, l'autre dans une salle du Quartier Latin. Faute d'entrées, les deux séances ont été déprogrammées à une semaine du rendez-vous. Il s'agit pourtant de films sélectionnés dans des festivals importants partout dans le monde, où ils ont reçu des prix. Il y a peut-être un manque de communication. Ou bien les festivals aussi ont perdu du crédit auprès du public."
Ou bien, troisième hypothèse, Independencia a mal fait son boulot.
Je ne vois pas l'intérêt de ces anecdotes qui renforcent plus l'idée que le rôle double du groupe producteur-editeur "Independencia" est contraire aux principes de "l'autonomie économique et rédactionnelle". Soit. Dans ce cas précis, en aparte, il semblerait que la main tendue d'Independencia fut pensée par ces critiques comme un échec programmé. Pour aider le bouche-à-oreille autour d'un petit film (qui sera vraissemblablement sorti dans un nombre limité de salles) il faut appâter le public en amont! Au plus tard, le jour même de la sortie... Croire qu'une "rencontre" deux semaines après la sortie soit d'une aide quelconque (quand la relance à l'affiche est décidée par les distributeurs à la suite des deux premières séances du mercredi matin!) relève d'une candeur totalement irresponsable! Il faut plus qu'un prix au FID de Marseille pour se payer la certitude de rester plus de deux semaines à l'affiche! Même à Paris. Pour des gars qui sont à la fois critiques et producteurs et distributeurs, je trouve ce genre d'attitude à la limite de l'inconscience...

"faire cohabiter indépendance et interdépendance."
C'est ici qu'ils veulent en venir avec ce joli laïus sur la déontologie!

"Independencia a entamé son existence en pratiquant une critique agressive et moraliste. Les lignes fondamentales de cette politique exprimaient dans notre premier éditorial et dans plusieurs textes plus ou moins polémiques vis à vis du cinéma d'auteur (Mia Hansen-Love, Olivier Assayas, Abbas Kiarostami...), des revues qui ont hérité et perpétuent la tradition des anciens Cahiers (Les Inrockuptibles, Libération et les Cahiers du cinéma), des festivals grands et petits (Cannes, Rome, vienne, Brive, La Roche-sur-Yon), et de certains cas particuliers voire, anecdotiques, de copinage. Reprenant une expression tirée de I'histoire, on pourrait appeler cette politique : 'critique de guerre' "
Effectivement, donner un 10/10 à Godard et un 0/10 à Kiarostami à Cannes 2010 fait preuve d'une grande maturité critique! On se croirait à l'Ecole des Fans... Ce n'est ni la guerre ni la morale, c'est un agitprop sensationaliste et prosélyte. Il ne suffit pas de taper sur les grands noms à tord et à travers pour se faire une réputation de rebel. La subjectivité et la complaisance des Cahiers jaunes, ça vous l'avez intégré... mais le talent reste à inventer!

Le temps est venu de passer à autre chose. Une 'intervention' récente (la numéro 10) annonce la volonté de fabriquer, dans un esprit d'artisanat, des objets divers. Dans un premier temps, l'édition papier et électronique de livres - ce qui constitue une extension naturelle et somme toute classique du travail d'une revue. Dans un second, la production et la distribution de films réalisés par des cinéastes que nous avons envie d'aider au-delà de l'écrit - ce qui est en revanche moins orthodoxe pour une revue. Moins orthodoxe, certes, mais répondant à une traduction actuelle de l'idée, certes ancienne, du critique passeur de films. Dans la pratique, cet engagement supplémentaire, ce militantisme de la critique occupant le domaine propre à la fabrication du cinéma comporte en revanche tout un tas de courts-circuits qui sont loin d'être innocents. L'urgence, lorsqu'on s'apprête à étendre le cercle de nos activités, est de définir clairement des bases éthiques. D'où la nécessité de proposer clairement une Nouvelle politique critique. Il s'agit de trouver un principe qui convienne à la réalité de toutes les activités entreprises, et qui puisse jouer un rôle régulateur dans l'interdépendance qui règne d'ores et déjà dans le monde du cinéma."
S'auto-publier est déjà un cercle vicieux où l'impératif de convaincre un éditeur de la valeur d'un texte disparaît complètement lorsqu'on publie pour écrire, au lieu d'écrire pour être publié. Mais passons, la connivence écriture-publication est une prérogative de la revue autonome.
La promiscuité critique-production est beaucoup plus vicieuse! Il ne s'agit pas de pervertir l'éthique afin que cette pratique devienne vertueuse... Ce conflit d'intérêt-là EST exactement le contraire absolu de la probité critique! Emmanuel Burdeau rêvait déjà en 2008 devenir juge et parti en toute impunité. Les éditions Capricci font la même chose, en publiant des livres exégètes dithyrambiques, et désormais une revue annuelle, sur les films qu'ils distribuent eux-même! C'est du marketing, de l'autopromotion, non sans intérêt, mais ça n'est pas un regard critique. 
Quant à la marchandisation de la revue, comme une vulgaire franchise Disney, on s'en tappe! Ca n'est pas un conflit d'intérêt pour la mission critique, c'est juste ridicule pour un groupuscule qui essaie de faire croire à une certaine "indépendence", "autonomie", et par dessus tout, une idéologie "marxiste" d'opérette pour BoBo. Alors c'est plus la peine de surfer sur des slogans révolutionnaire, anti-establishment, et d'indépendence.

Si vous souhaitez instituer un manifeste amoral, soit, mais ne prétendez pas que c'est une pratique "éthique".
Independencia n'aura pas duré 2 ans. La capitulation au capitalisme a déjà gagné!


Lire aussi :

20 janvier 2011

Eisenstein (Bouquet)



Conférence "Qui êtes-vous... Sergeï M. Eisenstein?" de Stéphane Bouquet
à la Cinémathèque Française (13 Jan 2011) 1h38' 

17 janvier 2011

Fétichisme hypermoderne (Wajcman)


Conférence de Gérard Wajcman : "Du fétichisme hypermoderne" 
le 17 novembre 2010 à la Cinémathèque Française 1h19'

16 janvier 2011

Cost Control Fail

What project can you produce with 3 million dollars?

Buried (2010/Rodrigo Cortés/ES/USA/FR)  estimated budget : $3 million
a 95 minutes long huis-clos, with a single actor (not even of B-list fame), 2 additional actors (for the 30 sec long cell-phone video), and a couple of voice actors (for the offscreen phone conversations), filmed entirely in a wooden box, little props (cellphone, lighter, knife, flash-light), one snake, and sand. That's all of it. You can film that in a couple of days.

or

Mistérios de Lisboa (2009/Raoul Ruiz/Portugal) estimated budget : €2 million (=$2.7 million)
a 6h long epic period drama TV mini-series (4h26 for the theatrical cut), with ensemble cast (over 60 actors), speaking in 4 different languages, shot in a couple of dozen locations (story spreading across 4 countries), plenty expensive costumes, XIXth century weapons, horses... Probably a couple of months of shooting.

while

Robin Hood (2010/Ridley Scott/USA) estimated budget = $210 million
it costs over 200 million dollar (70 times more!) to film another remake of Robin Hood, with a couple of A-list stars and lots of horses and extras. The price of 70 "three million dollar" films, such as the ones cited above. Does it worth it? It's not a CGI animation, nor a 3D movie. Hollywood really sucks at The Price Is Right.