12 avril 2011

Film School for Dummies

"Therefore, 'film school' -and the attitudes and stigmas commonly associated with it- does not necessarily require a new kind of analysis, for no new kind of analysis can exist for a sensibility that has been heretofore hardly been analysed. [..]
Unlike Godard, however, 'film school' wants to reverse the command that 'one should put everything into a film.' The new task: 'One should get a film out of everything' [..]
To become involved with a work of art entails, to be sure, the experience of detaching oneself from the world. But the work of art itself is also vibrant, magical, and exemplary object which returns us to the world."
Notes on Film School By: Ricky D'Ambrose (Undercurrent, Jan 2011)
Is it "good writing"? It doesn't even make sense... Anybody read this article on the editorial board at Undercurrent ? It's like nobody cares... Afterall the FIPRESCI isn't all that. It's a club of wannabe reviewers, it has nothing to do with world-class critical standards.
Are there any ideas? And nobody is scrutinizing this article on the interwebs since January! Everyone who read and linked to that thought it was alright? Where are the critics? You can't re-tweet everything you find and pause to actually read what you link to at the same time... or else you fall behind! Well you would need to understand what is wrong with this article too... Complacency is damaging Film Culture a lot, and even if you think it saves the ego of a wannabe who tries hard, it won't help him get any better! That's what happens when you don't go to school.


So what is the purpose of a Film School according to the International Federation of Film Critics??? (This should be easier for them to grasp than "ethics")
They think that learning filmmaking technique (such as editing, staging, lighting, acting, editing, production...) and deconstructing film screenings for aesthetic analysis (key light, fill light, colour filters, light temperature, focal length, microphone source, budget...) is overrated! Listen, if all this is a problem to you, if you're afraid it might "spoil" your artistic sensibility to acquire "too much" knowledge... one simple solution: DON'T GO TO UNIVERSITY !!! Many directors managed to make films without going to any film school and a few great filmmakers too.
The guy would like to have sex and remain virgin at the same time... He wants to learn how to make movies, without losing the innocence of the illiterate spectator. You can't unlearn filmmaking just to watch films... if you want to make films (or review them), you will fatally notice the technical flaws of a scene in a glance, or else you haven't watched enough films... That's why filmmakers (actors too) can't watch their own films, they only notice the smallest missed opportunities and the never-ending possible improvements. It is physically and mentally impossible to spend a few months (or years) on a project and not keep a highly critical, omniscient scrutiny on your own work. That is if you're any good at your job.

So his long "research" of the film education curriculum consists of an anti-intellectual rant against all the things everyone with common sense is expected to learn in a film university. Maybe what he needs is to go to Werner Herzog's non-school.
Werner Herzog: "You don't need to go to film school. You can learn the technical things in less than a week. All the rest you can learn by traveling on foot."
Masterclass, Thessaloniki Film Festival, Greece, 2009
By the way, I couldn't believe my eyes, the Cineaste magazine is advertising for a 2-day DVD course to learn everything you need to "make" films. And it's not just all technical aspects in 2 days... it's EVERYTHING : screenwriting, casting, budgeting, scheduling, financing, dealmaking, marketing, distributing, product placement... in 16 hours. What a big joke! You might sell a "Filmmaking for dummies" booklet with that, but not issue a "diploma" (included in the boxset!). Cineaste : "America's leading magazine on the art and politics of the cinema" yeah, right.
  • The Rogue Film School will not teach anything technical related to film-making. For this purpose, please enroll at your local film school.
  • The Rogue Film School is about a way of life. It is about a climate, the excitement that makes film possible. It will be about poetry, films, music, images, literature.
Excerpts of the Werner Herzog's Rogue Film School "convention" (since 2010)

I agree that what film universities teach today is conformist academism. Student films and debut features show they are more inspired by the commercial fare than by the vanguard of art films. Roger that. But I don't think it is impossible to learn acceptable knowledge and skills in a Film School, or that their teaching should be more sensible and less theoretical. No school will teach you talent, inspiration or genius... either you have it, or you cultivate it yourself. The function of a university is to teach you basic and advanced knowledge that can be taught, like technique and theory. Like Herzog says, the rest is up to you and your life experience (although in 2 weeks you will not learn all the technique needed to make Herzog's films, he's exaggerating!). There is no school for "feelings"! You're responsible to expose yourself to a variety of arts and life experiences to develop your sensibility. 


The main argument of this article is against a mentality called "Film School" by populists. Supposedly it is a snub trend amongst film universities, film students and commercial filmmakers who think highly of technique and aesthetics (allegedly eg. Jarmusch, Lynch, Kubrick, Anderson, Coppola, Coens bros., Tarantino, Wong Kar-wai, Haneke, Almodovar, Kurosawa, Lang's Metropolis, Demy's Les Parapluies de Cherbourg...) Really? You are angry against the quality of cinema they represent? So that's what FIPRESCI wants to trash today? Dude, watch their films... you might learn something.

And the only positive models cited are Akerman, Farocki, Godard and some Bergman. Do you really think everyone should make movies like Godard or Farocki? Yeah that would be a funny school if they only taught these films to film students. First, these are the kind of experimental filmmaking that does not mean to generate copycat disciples : so the idea of a film school teaching their ways to all students in America is a big misunderstanding. Second, this is an area of experimental cinema that would be hard to "teach", precisely because it's unconventional, and in school you learn conventions. A class on Godard would be way more theoretical than all the "technicality" you hate in classes on Scorsese or Wachowski. 
I see, this is probably another deluded fanboy who believes JLG is not a formalist, theoretician, technician but is all about improvisation and sensuousness.

I thought "film school" was a positive denomination amongst educated cinephiles. Reknown reviewer, Acquarello, actually titled her blog : Strictly Film School (since 1997). When I asked her, she said that the expression delimited the spectrum of titles covered by her selection, which excluded the mainstream fair, and pretty much means all "art cinema" (whatever this term means in America) that would be taught in film universities, and perceived as inaccessible/pretentious by the general audience. So it sounds to me like a positive and serious reference for cinephilia (even though it is used as a derogatory term by the mainstream viewers). Why would an article at the FIPRESCI diss that phrase, which is kinda "snob" already? Contrary to acquarello (who I'd rather trust), d'Ambrose made it seem like it represents "commercial", "sensationalism", "amusement", zealousness", "mannerism"... basically anything evil in cinema today. Why the discrepancy? Why the over-snobbery?

"FILM SCHOOL"
OPPOSED TO :
doing =
/ = thinking
pragmatist =
/ = intellectual
"common sense" =
/ = complexity
accessibility =
/ = difficulty, didacticism
archetypes =
/ = esoteric-ism
prevalence =
/ = uncommon
excitement =
/ = contemplativeness

"Common sense" opposed to "complexity"? I heard this before... (Contra-contrarianism 4)
I wonder why "good cinema" should be necessarily complex, difficult, esoteric... this is not at all a given. "Deep" opposed to "shallow" : yes; "challenging" opposed to "dumb" : yes; but simplicity, transparency and accessibility doesn't equate to bad, dumb and shallow films, necessarily. "Didacticism" is not the antonym to "accessibility", to the contrary!
And most of all complexity, difficulty and esoteric-ism directly contradicts the "contemplativeness" aspect, you gotta pick a side! For one thing, CCC (if that's what you care about) is not about "seriousness", "intellectualism", "effort", "thinking", "didacticism"... rather it is about evident simplicity and absence of intellectual constructions.
I am the most vocal supporter of contemplative cinema you can find (Unspoken cinema), yet, I'm not preaching to teach "contemplativeness" exclusively in ALL film schools. That would be absurd. CCC is not meant to substitute all other forms of storytelling. Film universities don't exist to format the taste of students and train them to make films only one way (the contemplative, intellectual, challenging way). Don't count on me to support this pamphlet just because it mentions "contemplativeness" (out of context)!
Like it or not, quality or not, traditional narrative is the bulk of film/TV storytelling in the world, and for more times to come, so there better be film schools that teach future directors how to get it right, if they go for the conventional job.
If you're writing a paper on the syllabi in today's film education, you need to be universal and stay objective. Even if you don't like commercial genres, the point of a film school, good or bad, is to teach the whole spectrum of genres and styles available to filmmakers. Film genres are not inherently bad, there are only bad directors. Great filmmakers can make wonders with the silliest genre. So if there is a problem in film education, it's not by limiting styles and techniques you're gonna fix it. You can become snob later, after you learnt the basics in school.

The author is so full of preconceptions about film techniques and stylistics devices... as if a long take had only one possible use, the one defined by Farocki. Instead of blaming BAD DIRECTORS, the article blames the technical devices (BADLY) used by (BAD) directors and rejects them altogether, with the whole generation they belong to.

So I'm not sure what is the mannerism disputed here... it's contradictory.
The talking points say anti-entertainment, by defining the "Film School" mentality with buzzwords such as "commercial interest", "accessibility", "excitement", "sensationalism", "irony", "speed", "fantastic", "shock", "diversion", "passivity", "lack of mental energy", "amusement", "sensation", "intensification of the image", "Mannerism", "edginess", slickness", "lack of interest in contemplativeness and seriousness", "love of aesthetic excitement and polish, of stylisation and velocity"...
Whereas the examples of guilty directors cited above say anti-intellectual, or anti-artsy.

This article doesn't know if it wants to be against commercial Hollywood or artsy cinema, against art filmmakers who became commercial or classic filmmakers who are too formalists, against theory or anti-intellectuals, against complexity or contemplativeness... I don't even know what the guy wants.

[..] More so than Resnais' films, the former [Christopher Nolan's films] easily align themselves with "film school" taste in their possibility for unambiguous advice about narrative structure, in their reliance on assimilability and convention. 
For instance, part of the speech is typical of the anti-Po-Mo arguments (dating back from the 90ies!) : against what postmodern films brought to cinema (recycling, homage, citation, parody, self-awareness, meta-narration, coolness, relativism, hyper-aesthetics, raw sensations, raw pleasure...), which is everything Godard does (yet he's the positive example cited here); since his very first film in 1959, he was a postmodern!

So the underlying repressed ideology I sense behind a discourse that pretends to be "pro-intellectual" is anti-education, anti-taxonomy, anti-technique, anti-form, anti-analysis, anti-criticism, anti-PoMo, anti-Mannerism (albeit a misplaced mannerism), and at least one constructive opposition : anti-commercial.
Usually anti-intellectuals who are against higher education are against high-brow Art and for mainstream entertainment. But there is a new kind of snobs (cultural studies) who have their own definition of "Art", the emotional art that theoreticians and critics don't understand and cannot express with words, allegedly. And they call the intellectual art, the sophisticated aesthetic, the conceptual experiment : "artsy".
Basically they pose as artfilm supporters, as "intellectuals" but they reject all the auteurs who had too much success (Almodovar, Coens, W. Anderson, Tarantino, Lynch, Aronofsky, Haneke, Wong Kar-wai, Fincher...) which is typical hipster oblivion : forward tabula rasa tactic.

At university you learn classics! Long-lived, safe classics. And the best of fairly recent filmmakers. You don't learn to become an experimental artist or the hip trend of next year in a traditional film school! In film school you learn how not to suck at filmmaking, which is already huge, and is apparently not even the minimal requirement to work in Hollywood. If EVERY film student learnt their shit from the lessons of film history, to make sure they don't make bad movies, the quality standard of mainstream entertainment would already raise above mediocre. Then we could turn some of them into artists.
But don't expect to come out of a film school with a know-how to make masterpieces. That would be too easy, don't you think? If you care about deep art and intellectual art, there is no reason to blame universities for not teaching you that. 

I'd agree that film departments in universities suck. Just by looking at what comes out of them. You might want to change the professors or the films studied... but a film school is a film school, it'll teach you technique and theory. Opening film departments to multidisciplinary courses and other arts is a great idea of course... but you still need to teach filmmaking techniques in a film school.


One good thing I note in this whole mess is the cry for more diversity in film nationality for the course syllabi. Too many American films used in American film schools! No wonder they keep repeating the Hollywood model over and over. But if they teach Kubrick, Jarmusch, Lynch, Tarantino, Coens brothers... that's solid material already, and they are not really "commercial" or "conformist".

And suddenly, the "film school sensibility" becomes synonymous with "intensified continuity", "image stylisation", "Mannerism"... in short : "American cinema over the past fifty years"! no less.
The simple mistake to put Lynch, Jarmusch, Coens, even Tarantino in the same bag with the "intensified continuity" that characterises cheap Hollywood spectacle kills the argument right there. Even if you pretend you defend a more intellectual cinema (which is disproven by the sloppiness of the article).

Anyone understands what was the point? There is no single consistent argument that holds everything together here. His examples are contradictory, even though he warns us against "reductio ad absurdum". Good ideas lost amidst ill-informed self-important subjective judgments make a lot of B.S.
I'm guessing that the guy has read a lot of interesting stuff, that were sound arguments in the first place, took short-hand notes he didn't understand and then tried to paraphrase the whole thing into something of his own that somehow justifies his distaste for the styles evoked. Result : fail. 

However bad this "film school mentality" is, I still think it's better than whatever the wrong-headed position this article puts forth. At this point I believe the main problem is bad professors and bad students which could get fixed eventually, without the dismantlement of film analysis, film theory, film technique, film education and films schools.


BONUS CLIP : Ricky D'Ambrose's own student film (2008) : a parody of NYU's student films (typical PoMo!)

Related :

Hong Sang-soo (La Cinémathèque)


entretien Hong Sang-soo
14 mars 2011 (lacinematheque) 7'53"

* * *

[video non dispo]
Conférence Hong Sang-soo (La Cinémathèque) 16 mars 2011

08 avril 2011

Contra-contrarianism (IFFR) 5



Good critic, Bad critic... what does it mean???
CRITICS KNOW: a BAD CRITIC is ... someone incompetent, dishonest, shallow, generalist, incoherent, subjective, complacent, lacks arguments, speculates, improvises summary judgements  a GOOD CRITIC is ... someone educated, skeptical, independent with objective analysis, facts, historical perspective, aesthetic standards, insights, ideas, opinions backed up by evidences
REVIEWERS ASSUME: a "BAD" CRITIC is ... someone who does negative criticism (called "tough love"),  dogmatic theory ("clichés"), [over-]analysis ("elitism", "spoilers"), love-deprived ("anti-cinephilia"), dialectic ("patronizing") a "GOOD" CRITIC is ... a "good" writer (a.k.a. thesaurus),  with positive promotion (cheerleader), impressions (truthiness), love (cinephilia), recommendations (prescription), trivia, anecdotes, puns
AUDIENCE FEELS: a "BAD" CRITIC is ... someone who dislikes what I like (attributed to "taste") a "GOOD" CRITIC is ... someone who likes what I like (taste)
Words mean different things to different people in different contexts. The problem is when two persons use the same word (with a different meaning) thinking they are talking about the same thing. And sometimes it means the contrary to what it is supposed to be used for.



05 avril 2011

Stanley Kubrick (La Cinémathèque)

Table ronde : "Stanley Kubrick, l'artiste et sa méthode"
La Cinémathèque Française, 24 mars 2011, 1h18'
Rencontre avec Ken Adam, Marisa Berenson, Michel Ciment, Nigel Galt, Jan Harlan, Christiane Kubrick, Tim Heptner, animée par Serge Toubiana.
  • 00:00:00 : Introduction
  • 00:04:04 : Napoleon, le rêve d'un film
  • 00:14:49 : Barry Lyndon, Docteur folamour : pré-production, décors et tournage
  • 00:36:48 : Être perfectionniste n’est pas un défaut
  • 01:06:36 : Questions des spectateurs
* * *

Exposition Stanley Kubrick à la Cinémathèque : 23 mars - 31 juillet 2011

* * *

Michel Ciment (France Culture, 16 avril 2011) 1h [MP3] avec:
  • Philippe Fraisse, auteur de « Le cinéma au bord du monde - Une approche de Stanley Kubrick » 
  • Pierre Berthomieu pour « Hollywood moderne - Le temps des voyants »
  • Sam Azulys pour son ouvrage « Stanley Kubrick, une odyssée philosophique » 
* * *


Michel Ciment à l'Institut Lumière, Lyon, 3 mai 2011 [1h27']

* * *


Michel Ciment: Entre raison et passion
26 avril 2011 (La Cinémathèque) 1h16'
Un fil rouge relie les films de Kubrick qui sont autant d’avertissements en forme de fables : le rapport au coeur de chaque homme et dans la société entre une volonté de contrôle, l’affirmation de la raison et l’irruption de la passion, de la violence et du refoulé.

Voir aussi :

04 avril 2011

French Critics Legacy 1

I was going to congratulate David Bordwell for writing about the state of Foreign Films on his blog (reviewing Tino Balio’s book : Foreign Film Renaissance on American Screens, 1946-1973), and then he says :
"Today we regard Citizen Kane as a classic, if not the classic. But for several years after its 1941 release it wasn’t considered that great. It missed a place on the Sight and Sound ten-best critics’ polls for 1952; not until 1962 did it earn a spot (though at the top). Its rise in esteem was due to changes in film culture and, some have speculated, the fact that Kane was a regular on TV during the 1960s. Something similar happened with His Girl Friday, another stealth classic."
I wonder what happened between the unpopular release of Citizen Kane in 1941 (dismissed by American critics!), and its canonization in 1962... at a time when Orson Welles was an Hollywood outcast, exiled in Europe, and making Le Procès (1962) in France. Maybe André Bazin's support from 1946 (when American films could be seen in France again after the war) to 1956, while the American didn't care for it, had something to do with it?
  • Citizen Kane, André Bazin, Parisien Libéré April 07, 1946
  • La technique de Citizen Kane, André Bazin, Temps modernes February 1947
  • Je plaide pour Orson Welles, André Bazin, Ecran Français January 20, 1948
  • L'apport d'Orson Welles, André Bazin, Ciné-club May 1948
  • Orson Welles, André Bazin, 1950
  • Dossier secret Orson Welles ou la volonté de puissance, André Bazin, Radio Cinéma Télévision June 17, 1956
Or maybe it was the power of TV broadcast that turned an outcast into a star... Sure. Let's credit popular TV for the reversal of an elitist canon like Sight and Sound's decennial top10. I'm afraid he mixes up the (belated) popularity of a film within general culture, due to TV exposition, with the critical appreciation of a masterpiece by an elite circle of critics (also quite late).
Bordwell dedicated an entire post to Bazin, to unearth his alledged "plagiarism" by misquoting him, but he wouldn't namedrop his name here, to acknowledge his key role in the reappraisal of Orson Welles' reputation in the world... Convenient memory lapse. Unfair.
He cites Film Comment and Film Culture, but not Cahiers du cinéma (translated by Andrew Sarris in 1966-67) which did such a good job at saving Hollywood films' reputation from the neglect of the American press?
What hope is left if even historians are biased and revisionist in America?
The excuse of French critics to wait till 1946 to rediscover Citizen Kane... was WORLD WAR II ! What is the excuse of American critics???

At least, I welcome the often forgotten mention that the unbeatable number 1 masterpiece on all canonical lists : Citizen Kane, didn't always enjoy this unconditional love in America. It's easy to confess, today, that Citizen Kane is your favourite film of all time... but sadly, Orson Welles had rough times with Hollywood, the American audience and the American critics because of it, to begin with. 
"[Tino Balio] is asking a business question: What led the U. S. film industry to accept and eventually embrace films so fundamentally different from the Hollywood product?
Several researchers have pointed to the roles played by influential critics, film festivals, and new periodicals like Film Comment and Film Culture."
The question of canon formation is an interesting investigation. I do think that the golden age of Hollywood consumerism until the 50ies (before the competition with TV), which fortunately coincided with a peak in quality creation (within the studio system), influences greatly the favouritism towards this period in cinema history. They made great films back then, indeed, but they also benefited from other factors which favourably exaggerated their importance, like the fact that a lot more spectators went to the movies at the time, that most influential critics and publications (and later filmmakers) came of age during this period, that art cinema was more popular than today, that cinema culture in general was a lot less controversial and polarized than today... All this results in the fact that in the collective memory, this period combines more positive sentiments than any following periods. And when lists are tabulated, the lowest common denominator is the less controversial masterpiece, ranked on top by the majority of voters. Since critics polled are often over 60 years old, they are most likely influenced by the aura of this Golden Age, during their impressionable years. Later critics are then influenced in turn by the authority of this period established by their elders.

But does it mean that Bergman or Kurosawa were overrated? Seriously? Can we say today (even by acknowledging the exceptional conjuncture) that a Bergman masterpiece or a Kurosawa masterpiece doesn't live up to the hype? This is ridiculous. I would rather re-evaluate, in hindsight, the cult of personality around the persona (which overcompensates the actual "superiority" of their films) of Godard, Truffaut, Chabrol, Renoir, Wyler, Hawks, Wilder, Donen, Curtiz, Lean, Laughton, Capra, Nicolas Ray... (I know how terribly subversive it is to dare claim such thing!) before thinking of revising the canonical merits of Bergman's (Cries and Whispers, The Virgin Spring, Winter Light, Persona, Shame, Scenes from a Marriage, The Silence, Hour of the Wolf, The Passion of Anna) and Kurosawa's (Rashomon, The Seven Samurai, Stray Dog, Throne of Blood, High and Low, The Bad Sleep Well, Yojimbo, Sanjuro) best films (within the 1946-73 timeframe). TV broadcast and distribution in the USA have nothing to do with the worldwide recognition of their talent!

Personally I believe that the 60ies gave us more masterpieces (Antonioni, Resnais, Bergman, Cassavetes, Satyajit Ray, Pollet, Kubrick...) than the preceding decades of Sound Cinema, and the more recent masterpieces made by Tarkovsky, Kubrick, Lynch, Kiarostami and Tarr should be rated higher comparatively to the conservative taste of the Golden Age classics (40-50ies). The aesthetic challenges and discoveries made since then are of higher magnitude than what the 40ies was in comparison to the achievements of the Silent era. The degree of risks and improvements are superior today, for the few masters, while the aesthetic qualities of commercial cinema today is inferior to what it was in the Hollywood of Hitchcock, Ford, Lang or Welles.

The question Bordwell conveniently forgets to ask is : What happened to the distribution of Foreign Films in the USA after 1973??? (see a graph of Foreign Film admissions in the USA between 1985 and 2008 here)

Last week, Quattro Volte (like Alamar last autumn) opened in the USA on 1 single screen (NYC)!!! despite raving reviews. This is a shame for the American distribution system and shame on American intellectuals (or art lovers) for not caring about it.
Apparently it doesn't justify a particular attention from the Press that a new (foreign) film is given such a bad chance to meet an audience in this competitive market... it doesn't move the American critics, it doesn't trigger an outrage, a revolution... They no longer fulfill their function of watchdogs in Film Culture. What really offends them is that a 3D movie was retrofitted in postproduction rather than shot in 3D! What are we gonna do with these guys, seriously??? 

In 50 years, someone will write a book on The Foreign Film Demise on American Screens : 1973-2061, and the indifferent press will be remembered. Do you realize that?


Related:

    02 avril 2011

    Contra-contrarianism (IFFR) 4

    Some definitions from the official dictionary that allows our society to communicate with a common language...

    Common Sense
    Common Sense : "the ability to use good judgment and make sensible decisions" (MacMillan Dictionary)
    Not to confound with :



    Comfort Zone
    "The temperature range between 28° and 30°C or 82.5° and 86°F at which the naked body maintains heat balance without shivering or sweating"
    (The American Heritage Stedman's Medical Dictionary)
    Originally the Comfort Zone is beneficial to our biological system. We don't need sunburns or ice burns to prove we are alive. Not everybody needs to risk their life to feel alive. No reason to blame the general population (or the general audience) if they want their "comfort clothes", "comfort food", "comfort movies"...

    The problematic is different when we talk about a specific group : critics. We expect critics to exceed their comfort zone because they are not the average movie goer, they do not watch movies for their own selfish comfort (not exclusively at least I hope), they are only paid to provide an educated advice to other movie goers, not to indulge their own idiosyncratic narcissistic envy, fantasy and pleasure (film writers often forget that!) that reinforce a craved sense of security (their comfort zone).

    " The comfort zone is a behavioural state within which a person operates in an anxiety-neutral condition, using a limited set of behaviours to deliver a steady level of performance, usually without a sense of risk. A person's personality can be described by his or her comfort zones. [..] A comfort zone is a type of mental conditioning that causes a person to create and operate mental boundaries. Such boundaries create an unfounded sense of security. "
    (Wikipedia)
    The figurative meaning of the phrase, applied specifically to critical/competitive professions (always seeking to be off the edge, ahead of the curve) takes a new turn. In this particular condition, being safe, limiting yourself to artificial boundaries, sticking to your comfort zone might be detrimental to the practice of your job. It doesn't mean that EVERY critic MUST reject their comfort zone and throw themselves into a fastforward race to the next novelty, the random unknown, the unique stuff that nobody else promotes... Because this kind of attitude (that exists in certain hipster quarters) has the anarchical tendency to call conservative (or comfort zone) anything déjà-vu. The crucial difference is how you define what is the "comfort zone" and what is revolutionary.
    We've seen how some critics feel better about themselves by trashing so-called "non-fast cinema" as if it was a (homogeneous) style that lasts too long, looks too old, out of touch with MTV frantic cutting... Totally oblivious of a wider context where "intensified continuity" is just as old and a very superficial imitation of contemporary technologically-addict lifestyles. It's all a matter of point of view. Yet certain critics are entrenched in their certitude that fast=good and slow=bad, no matter what. They are in their own comfort zone. And we could just as well burst that bubble.
    Preconceived ideas, prejudices, contrived biases do not help to get Film Discourse to higher planes...

    " A foolish consistency is the hobgoblin of little minds, adored by little statesmen and philosophers and divines. With consistency a great soul has simply nothing to do. He may as well concern himself with his shadow on the wall. Speak what you think now in hard words, and to-morrow speak what to-morrow thinks in hard words again, though it contradict every thing you said to-day. — ‘Ah, so you shall be sure to be misunderstood.’ — Is it so bad, then, to be misunderstood? Pythagoras was misunderstood, and Socrates, and Jesus, and Luther, and Copernicus, and Galileo, and Newton, and every pure and wise spirit that ever took flesh. To be great is to be misunderstood."
    (Ralph Waldo Emerson, Self Reliance, 1841)
    LOL. Seeking misunderstanding with everyone else to insure being above everyone else... This is confusing the incidental end with the performative means. I'm not so sure that whenever you are misunderstood, you are therefore profound. In fact, I'm pretty sure that is the definition of an ignorant in the overwhelming majority of cases. The value of these few geniuses cited is not defined by being misunderstood by an outdated paradigm (incidental and unfortunate) but by being understood by the new paradigm (groundbreaking leap forward). 
    In Europe we are Cartesian (Descartes, champion of reason), in America they are empiricists (Emerson, champion of individualism)... We believe empiricism is anti-intellectual, they believe rational thinking is elitist. That explains the cultural gap right there.
    How ironic that 50 of the top100 best world universities are American, yet the American general public is amongst the most anti-intellectual, as if the American intelligentsia was insular, disconnected from its duty to educate its own fellow Americans. 
    That's what we have to deal with, when we engage the uphill battle against the humongous colossus that is the Hollywood culture hegemony throughout the world. And film writers who don't care about the absence of foreign film screenings in their country, the absence of critical debate, the dictature of the marketing talking points, the dumbification of the masses... are no critic at all.


    Conformity
    " Conformity is the act of matching attitudes, beliefs, and behaviors to what individuals perceive is normal of their society or social group. This influence occurs in small groups and society as a whole, and may result from subtle unconscious influences, or direct and overt social pressure. Conformity can occur in the presence of others, or when an individual is alone. For example, people tend to follow social norms when eating or watching television, even when alone. "
    (Wikipedia)
    It's rather easy to mock the misconceptions, the outdated taste of distant generations... but it's another thing to be able to have the critical distance to judge clearly OUR controversies in OUR time as they unfold, without falling for the conventional wisdom bandwagon. We only need statistics to figure what is the opinion the majority of people go for, but it takes critical thinking to sift insights from fads.
    It's all dandy to toss around words like "out of the comfort zone"... but what did you do to prove you oppose the inertia of the populist self-indulgence???

    Criticism is for defiant reflection not for self-congratulatory fascination.
    "Le motif de la résistance, c'est l'indignation." Stéphane Hessel, 2011


    Related :

    English Fail


    At TEDxDubai, longtime English teacher Patricia Ryan asks a provocative question: Is the world's focus on English preventing the spread of great ideas in other languages? (For instance: what if Einstein had to pass the TOEFL?) It's a passionate defense of translating and sharing ideas.

    28 mars 2011

    Ad Hominem in Critical Debate (Adrian Martin)

    Here is the infamous email I mentioned in a previous post (Alert: Australia is censoring the internet!). Adrian Martin didn't even bother to send a reply to my reply. And he was not able to appreciate the fact I didn't post it on my blog right away (because such low blow isn't even worth giving it attention), it didn't give him enough time (almost 1 year) to reflect on the silliness of his ill-informed and anti-critical reaction. He didn't once try to apologize either...
    Well, hoping the private resolution of a conflict is not a mistake I'll repeat again with disrespectful and hypocritical individuals who blame others of (imagined) libel after resorting to Ad Hominem themselves.
    [Title : Ahem !! / Date : 2nd April 2010 / Sender : Adrian Martin]
    Hey, I was very moved by your blog confession [he refers to this post : Cinéma d'auteur blasé (1)] that you begged the INDIAN AUTEUR editors to remove my recent (and in fact longstanding and long-expressed in public) thoughts on auteurism !! [he refers to his interview in INDIAN AUTEUR #7]
    You yourself are turning auteurism 'European style' into a kind of dogma in your recent blog entries !! We fully agree on this: that making good films is the goal - or at least the goal of filmmaking itself !! When I talk about 'auteurism' (rather than filmmaking practice) I am talking about critical writing, critical method: and, from THAT angle, concentrating on the author is not always the most illuminating or best way to go. It can be a reduction, as as has been proved many times !!!
    Also, you are wrong in thinking that the 'a film by' syndrome has no industrial/legal ramifications: it is the very basis of the studio contract of the 'director's cut' !!! [apparently he didn't read this post: Parallel evolutions of auteurism]
    Back to the creativity of filmmaking practice: is the best way to arrive at a good film for the director to assume total or major control over the elements of a production? Probably so: I would agree with you there. But there are many 'strong' directors (in TV too) in this sense who have no 'auteur' personality or discernible signature: they just get their job done, and do it well !! Your 'art vs industry' polarisation is not making a lot of persuasive sense to me here.
    And as for the 'danger' you imply in exposing our Indian friends to any criticism of the holy dogma of the auteur: come on, that is just a little bit racist of you, in its implication if not its intention !!!!!!
    I will now retire to sleep and continue pondering the fickleness of critical fortune ...
    Ahem !!
    ADRIAN M.
    and my (ignored) reply :
    [Date: 6 April 2010 / Sender: HarryTuttle]
    Bonjour Adrian,
    ça faisait longtemps que je n'ai pas reçu de vos nouvelles. Je vais bien, merci. Et vous-même?
    "Ahem !!" ? C'est comme ça que vous accueillez la discussion critique?
    Si vous souhaitez un droit de réponse, je me ferai un plaisir de publier ce présent email sur mon blog et d'y répondre pour justifier mes positions, le cas échéant.
    Si cette interview s'était déroulée normalement, sans intermédiaire, je vous aurai retourné mes commentaires directement avant la publication. Il y a quelques questions auxquelles vous avez choisi de ne pas répondre aussi...
    En résumé, notre désaccord repose, il me semble, sur votre généralisation des clichés issus de la mauvaise, superficielle critique dite "auteuriste" et de rejeter dans le même mouvement toute approche auteuriste quelle qu'elle soit...
    Chacun ses goûts.
    Bonne journée,
    HT
    My contentious post was an objective critical reading of his off-kilter (anti-auteurist) response in a interview given to an auteurist journal. It was posted 5 months later, precisely to avoid an intentional muddy distraction around the date of publication of a journal I participated in. But he didn't even understand my own precaution, and even though he subscribes to Filmkrant's so-called "slow criticism" every year, he still starts his email by reproaching me my "late" after-the-fact response... 

    He says I "begged" to remove a paragraph in his long interview. In my post I said I "suggested" (I asked once, they didn't reply, I gave up). Critical minds like precision.

    My suggestion was sent out in private to the editor. This is a totally legit (pre-publication) debate around the modalities of publication of any article. EVERY newspapers and magazines edit their interviews!!! EVERYBODY knows (I would hope that an ex-journalist like Adrian Martin would know about it). Page space is expensive in the paper Press, and they make decisions to cut out the fat, which makes the published content all the more snappy and to the point. This is not covert censorship. Interviewee agree to being edited by accepting an interview. This is precisely why people usually complain about their words being taken out of context or truncated. In this case, I only wanted 1 question and 1 response out, which had a separate subject and would not compromise the reading of the rest of the interview.

    Why? Because he misunderstood the question, and rambled off-topic. Honestly I was doing him a favor by sorting this out before the publication. My question was asking about the limitation of auteurism, knowing that Adrian was an auteurist himself (as I am myself). I expected him to identify my question as the expression of the usual detractor argument opposed to auteurism, to give him the chance to acknowledge in his answer the point of view of detractors and take this opportunity to defend auteurism and explain in a pedagogical way why the anti-auteurist position was wrong-headed... He failed. He thought that an auteurist journal cared about giving more exposition to anti-auteurist arguments. We can't use his answer in a journal which goal is to implant auteurism deeper in the land of Bollywood. If the editors did their job, and stuck to the manifesto they publish in every issue, they would have asked Adrian Martin, who couldn't possibly refuse unless he was a megalomaniac retard [EDIT: people with difability] who thought that the integrity of his unedited interview was more important for his career than to help this amateurish journal to realise its alleged mission. 
    Excerpt from the Indian Auteur manifesto (1st Jan 2009):
    "[..] We reject a system that encourages the above, despite its realization, and seek: [..] To work towards a film love which adopts a middle ground, to reinstate the cinema director to his deserved position, to celebrate Indian cinema of the past and the present, to examine its potential, we propose “The Delhi manifesto.”
    If Adrian Martin wanted to promote anti-auterism, maybe it wasn't the right time or the right venue to do so... especially since he doesn't know how to review a film without using the auteurist jargon (see the comments in this post for a telling example). Obviously, his irrational attachment to a position that isn't his, was completely unexpected and inappropriate.

    A year and a half after this interview, he writes his first non-auteurist article in Filmkrant (Jan 2011) and declares [a piece from a series on "Out of the Comfort Zone"]: 
    "Film criticism (slow or fast, it's all the same) has to give up its abundant fantasies of judgement, discernment, purity [..] To do that, it will need to discard some of its hard-won habits and rituals, and open itself to first-time surprises. [..] ...And this is a first for me, for example: I have managed to write an entire article without mentioning a single film director's name." 
    If it was "out of his comfort zone" to write an auteur-less article in 2011, maybe he wasn't really challenging the auteurist ways back in 2009! Hard to tell with guys who flash a disclaimer at any skeptics : "One thing I truly believe is that real critics and real cinephiles should have absolutely no track with common sense". Yeah, we can't really fault someone who warns you they are not going to make sense ahead of time...

    Now about Adrian Martin's understanding of racism, and its trivialization to avoid having to justify his clumsy interview.

    Basically our point of disagreement was whether it was pertinent to talk about "anti-auteurism" in this time and place. He frames it as if I was against discussing the limitations of auteurism (while I was the one who wrote in that question in his interview!!!), or against exposing Indian Auteur's readers to non-auteurist scholarship. 
    Nitesh, editor of Indian Auteur, could testify that I tried to dissuade his idea that there was no Indian-Indie-friendly scholars in all India (or I could post my emails). 
    Apparently, Adrian Martin (head of Film and Television Studies at Monash University) cannot comprehend the idea that defending an editorial line (established by the Indian Auteur team, not me!) might justify selecting the content that will be part of the journal, in order to increase supporters to their cause (auteurist criticism in India), rather than growing the ranks of detractors infatuated with the Bollywood star-system. How is that anti-Indian or "a bit racist in its implications" (as he puts it) on my part????? Philosopher my ass!
    The simple fact that I'm not Indian, according to him, makes the formulation of any criticism against the content of such or such Film department of an Indian university automatically "racist". NON FUCKING SEQUITUR DUDE!

    This is so underhanded and shameful to "poison the well" with the racist card, just to bail out of the debate (the fact he didn't reply to my reply, wherein I spared him the Ad Hominem notification, says it all about his intention to engage with the disagreement on an intellectually honest level!)
    And this hypocrite dares to patronise me : "You don't know anything about me or my life or my work" before insulting someone. I doubt he knows enough "about me, my life, my work" to chance an insult of "racism"! 

    Racism is a serious matter and very dangerous (especially in the wake of recent elections in France where the far-right FN unfortunately gained in popularity... which soiled the honor of my country!), and nobody should use this fallacious trump card to get out of a purely INTELLECTUAL argument. Abuse of (irrelevant) calls to racism attack will only undermine the actual meaning of this threat, and dull up the attention of readers for REAL racism!
    *IF* the Indian scholars sucked (which is not my position as stated above), and *IF* I said so, it would NOT be a racist comment, but a purely intellectual evaluation of the CONTENT of their writing. Yes it is possible to disagree with scholars from a different country! It is part of the CRITICAL DISCOURSE, if you respect cross-examination and the right to criticism. And if my critical evaluation turned out to be wrong, it would disprove my point, it wouldn't make me a racist!

    N.B. There is such a thing as "racist discriminations", sadly. But there is only ONE SINGLE race of human beings on Earth, there is no distinction needed on a racial level between populations or countries. We are all the same. Racism is ALWAYS a flawed form of exclusion. (See if critics cared about ethics...)

    How ironic, the guy who calls Apichatpong, "Joe", in a print article, calls me a "racist" !

    This is the guy who lectures me about collaborating with our "Indian friends" :
    [Film-Philosophy mailing-list / 1 Oct 2009]
    Would everyone who - like me - is thoroughly sick and tired of receiving the UNSOLICITED and utterly fatuous emails of INDRA KARAN please let this annoying person know in no uncertain terms that you are mad as hell and will not take it anymore! Since IK appears to be using the FILM-PHILOSOPHY mailing list as their personal mail-out line, it would be good for us to put our foot down on this collectively - OVER HALF A DOZEN REQUESTS from me to this person have not yet stopped the email abuse.
    in swolidarity with everybody but Indra Karan, ADRIAN
    Read the following messages to learn that this angry Adrian Martin was the only one receiving these unsolicited emails and that most respectable members defended this sympathetic Indian fellow (newly member), attacked by a bunch of intolerant and English-spelling control freaks on the list. 
    I was shocked when I read this uncalled-for intervention in my in-box, coming from a "doctor in philosophy" (I guess they don't teach philoxeny and politeness in his philosophy curriculum), on a forum destined to strictly intellectual discussions (i.e. philosophical discussions!) 

    A shame for any human being in general. And someone who calls himself a "film critic" MUST know better, by the very NATURE of his discipline!!!! The probity of Film Criticism isn't fixed soon...

    smh


    Related:

    25 mars 2011

    Exploding traditional narrative structure (Kubrick)

    Entretien de Michel Ciment avec Stanley Kubrick, 1987, Childwickbury, UK
    (webcast France Culture, 24 March 2011) 29'
    Ciment: "Comment un cinéaste aujourd'hui peut affronter le fait que les spectateurs sont constament abreuvés d'images de la guerre, particulièrement à la TV? Comment créer des images nouvelles pour que le public voie différement?"

    Kubrick: "Well, since I have always found it easy to make the visual side of movies I've never really worried about it. I think the problem with audience is story. Movies are not disappointing because they are disappointing visually. They are disappointing because they are just boring. And there is nothing about them that really moves you or gets your imagination. So I would say the problem is more where do good stories come from? Is there ever gonna be a way to combine the structure of the silent movies with the quick presentation of an idea in a TV commercial? Maybe a poet has to do it. I don't know. A novelist will never do it. A playwright will never do it. And if you're not a [filmmaker-]writer, you'll probably never do it. So somewhere, somebody has to tie the wonderful economical structural possibilities of a silent movie with the tremendous power a good TV commercial can generate on a topic in 30 seconds. I still think this will be the most exciting thing that happened since whoever was that cut the two first films together and realised you could have editing. You really need a sort of editing of the mind, which hasn't happened. Somewhere somebody has to bring this together, just tell a story in a different way." 

    Related:

    24 mars 2011

    Naissance et dévelopement du parlant (Verscheure)

    1. Les premiers systèmes sonores - Naissance et dévelopement du parlant (Jean-Pierre Verscheure) 1h47'
    12 novembre 2010 - La Cinémathèque Française, Paris.

    L’histoire du cinéma sonore débute véritablement avec les premiers films dialogués qui marquent une transformation fondamentale du langage filmique. Une nouvelle forme de narration naît avec Le Chanteur de Jazz, et d’une manière plus significative encore avec L’Ange bleu ou Lights of New-York. A partir des équipements Vitaphone de la Western Electric de 1927 (le projecteur à disque, le premier haut-parleur de l’histoire du cinéma), jusqu’au système RCA Photophone mis au point pour Orson Welles en 1940, les sons du cinéma parlant seront présentés et diffusés dans leur forme originelle lors de cette conférence, ce qui permettra une comparaison inédite et spectaculaire des différents systèmes. Des premiers balbutiements des années Vingt à la Seconde Guerre mondiale, nous retracerons à travers ces projections la révolution sonore des techniques, ses implications pour l’industrie du cinéma et l’évolution des standards qui découlèrent de ces nouveaux procédés. Des appareils anciens et rarissimes seront exposés.
    • 1ère partie : La mise au point du cinéma sonore et les trusts américains.
    • 2ème partie (à partir de la 44ème minute) : L’évolution du son du Chanteur de jazz à la Seconde Guerre mondiale.
    Jean-Pierre Verscheure est professeur à l’Institut National Supérieur des Arts du Spectacle (INSAS) de Bruxelles. Collectionneur d’appareils cinématographiques, il est à l’origine d’un centre d’études sur les techniques cinématographiques, Cinévolution, dans lequel plus d’une quarantaine d’installations sonores ou visuelles d’époque ont pu être restituées permettant de présenter les films dans leurs conditions de projection d’origine.

    Historique général :
    • avant 1895 : Préhistoire du cinéma
      • 1894 : Premier film sonore (Edison)
    • 1895-1927 : Période muette
    • 1927-1952 : Période Academy
      • 1930 : Fin des monopoles de breuvets industriels (Western electric/RCA)
      • 1947 : Standardisation des normes de diffusion sonore dans les salles
    • 1952/57-aujourd'hui : Période de l'écran large et de la stéréophonie
      • 1977 : Dolby A - SR / Ultra Stéréo / DTS analog
      • 1990 : CDS / Dolby SR-D / SDDS / DTS



    September 1894 to April 2, 1895, in Edison's Black Maria studio.
    Cameraman: William Heise. Library of Congress, USA
    Experimental sound film made for Edison's kinetophone -- a combination of the kinetoscope and phonograph -- but apparently never distributed. The LC copy is silent. Features two men [W.K.L. Dickson or Charles D'Almaine] dancing to a violinist.

    22 mars 2011

    Alert: Australia is censoring the internet!

    "That's why his online journal, Rouge (where most of the articles are his) didn't publish anything in 2 years. That's why he promised since 2006 and never made an online archive site for all his articles... That's how much he believes in the internet (the instantaneousness of internet). I believe what I see. I'm not moved whatsoever by political pandering."
    I give you 24 hours to remove these sorts of libellous statements from your blog site. You don't have a clue what you are talking about in these regards. You don't know anything about me or my life or my work. Just recall, if you can, that I was someone who encouraged you and and published you.
    ADRIAN MARTIN (email 22 March 2011)
    OMG I'm gonna change my FB status to "threatened".
    A "real critic" would retort, rebut, refute, rebuff, confound, confute, debunk, disconfirm... You know, sticking with verbal engagement, and rational reasoning. But he chose CENSORSHIP. That's not very "open-minded", or "critical". Maybe he knows more about "fascistic methods" than I gave him credit for after all. That's very interesting. He believes he has the right to be the editor of my own personal blog!

    Quick reality check : when you publish in a well known institutional newspaper, or when you speak out on a mass media like TV, or when you speak in the name of an entire profession, say, at an international festival... you don't just speak for yourself, you commit the reputation of your host, and your responsibility for what you say is proportional to the size of the readership/audience.
    On the other hand, when you write in a personal diary, such as a blog, you only engage yourself (whoever that is). Try be Justin Bieber for a day, you will swiftly give up the hope that you can control the way individual people in the world talk about you on their blogs... Control freak!

    Why the hurry? I think he watches way too many American TV series...
    Since he kindly refers to my article published in Rouge, "CNN's election night hologram", I asked for a correction after publication, because I credited an eight-way split screen to CNN instead of CNBC. It took him over 2 weeks (the "instantaneousness of the internet" he told me when he asked me to translate this article from French to English within 1 or 2 weeks! last minute call for a magazine that barely publishes once a year!!! plus another film review, which I didn't do cause I'm not working a full-time job for him)  to copy/paste the sentence I emailed him to correct a HTML page on his website! I can tell he's got double standards when it comes to right a wrong, especially when it's about HIM.
    Libel : "a written or oral defamatory statement or representation that conveys an unjustly unfavorable impression"
    Apparently he thinks that stating facts is defamatory to him... Rouge didn't publish since 2009 (fact). His filmcritic.com.au personal archive grand opening is still pending (fact). 
    The only inaccuracy would be "most of the articles are his", which is clearly a sarcastic hyperbole (good luck taking that to court!), just like he wrote in Filmkrant (March 2011) : "More usually, minimalist/contemplative films end with murders by shooting or knifing" which is demonstrably false, but it doesn't stop him from stating it, not as a personal opinion on his own blog, but in an official magazine! Will he correct it within 24h?? He's giving bad publicity to "contemplative cinema"... Nobody is going to sue him for it.

    Headline : "Humorless film critic declares war on sarcasm"... you have a chance to earn a segment on theonion.com !

    When more than 2 of the articles (per issue) in a magazine are yours, the editor's, you're dangerously slipping in self-promotion and auto-publication. Nothing prohibited here, unless you have journalistic ethics... I'm merely pointing at the obvious, is it defamatory to suggest he publishes more of his own articles than any other single contributor in his magazine?
    The rest of my quote is only me sharing my opinion, which doesn't have to be true, since I only speak for myself. If the opinion police was effective, all of this Rotterdam roundtable would have been censored. 
    Am I still allowed to declare : "I believe what I see. I'm not moved whatsoever by political pandering." or is it defamatory to Mister Adrian Martin? We're not under the Soviet regime, you know. People are allowed to express opinions in the free world.

    Who cares about Mister Adrian Martin's personal life? Is that his excuse to cop out of a legitimate criticism of his declarations? More than anybody else, a critic should respect and defend the freedom of expression and critical scrutiny. "Criticism" isn't only about things you agree with, you gotta accept and defend criticism that is unfavorable to you too (especially when the statements criticized are a lot of B.S.), like Voltaire. Your life has nothing to do with this. As soon as you make the choice to jump on your soapbox and make public declarations, you should be aware of the consequences, and prepare to be accountable for everything you say. That's the price of celebrity. Deal with it, or stick to your personal life away from public criticism.

    Parting reminder : he insinuates that since he published one article for me, I "owe" him. Does he actually imply that granting exposition to my article (in a publication celebrating critical values) somehow strips me of my right to criticize anything concerning him, like if I was his vassal? He's got a disturbing perception of the duty and privileges of an editor. 
    If I had to balance, upfront, the publication of an article with my future liberty to speak up on anything he writes or says, there is no doubt in my mind I would have declined the offer, clearly and definitely, for its dodgy bargain, if not out of critical principles.
    I published one new article of his, Chantal Akerman : Walking Woman, unedited, at Unspoken Cinema too... Apparently it doesn't mean anything to him. He didn't even notify me when he re-published it in a Chilean edition ( in ¿Qué es el cine moderno?), didn't even credit the Unspoken Cinema blog for first publishing it... (that's how much he supports the internet over the Press!) But who cares? Double standards all the way! Did he pay me respect because of it? No. He insulted me by email, calling me "racist" (ME a racist? Are you fucking kidding me???), just because I expressed my disagreement about an arguable theoretical point in an interview of him I happened to have prepared (for Indian Auteur)!  Is that how you deal with adversity and dissent, you just play the "racist card"? (see : Ad Hominem in Critical Debate (Adrian Martin)) You should be ashamed. Obviously, this is a man who is very cautious about libel and knowing people's personal lives before calling them names... How I hate hypocrites!!!

    Of all the critical points I raised about this Rotterdam roundtable, he takes offence for this harmless quote??? 
    If he wasn't against "common sense" he would have gone for the easier angle... 
    I misquoted his Sight and Sound article, but I already corrected by myself (before his threatening email), because I had a doubt about my recollection and double-checked at the library. He cited Wong kar-wai and Tsai Ming-liang (not Haneke, which probably comes from elsewhere).
    The "We created Apichatpong's celebrity into existence" speech doesn't come from this particular article as well, I read it somewhere else apparently. 
    He could also take exception about me not listing Raul Ruiz (one entire issue dedicated to him) in my Rouge survey, since it is a named mentioned on the roundtable. But he's the only one namedropping Ruiz. The names of contention repeated by almost everyone, were Tarr, Diaz, Alonso... who embody for the British press the "slow festival film" decadence that caused so much noise this past year. Ruiz wasn't part of it at any point.
    My point was that Rouge is mostly about older films and filmmaker (and this is verifiable), not really about very recent cinema (post-2000) like he claimed.
    He could also complain that he mentioned an Australian name, his newspaper co-worker, which disproves the 100% American namedrop. Although, no offence, his colleague is not a referential figure like Ebert or Rosenbaum.


    Instead of welcoming a critical debate, with a new point of view and some legit objections, people who call themselves critics resort to censorship to shut down any possible debate. I think it's sad. Unfortunately, it's not the kind of attitude that will improve the climate of film discourse... Don't you dare qualify my rational arguments of typical unsubstantiated blogosphere drivel. I took the time to engage with your reflexion and I respected your quotes, which context is freely verifiable at the links I respectfully provided. 


    Please contact my lawyers for further negotiations. ;)
    Oh by the way, I'm still interested in your articles on Apichatpong, Costa, Diaz, Tarr that you mentioned on the roundtable and that I'm not aware of. 

    P.S. I post this here, cause he only replies to emails when he wants. And I just do not email people who don't email back.


    Related:

    19 mars 2011

    Table ronde : critique et internet (2008)

    La critique de cinéma et le défi d'internet: de la revue au blog

    Roundtable organised at La Cinémathèque Française (2008-07-06) in Paris.
    MP3 and Video available at Canal U (FRENCH, 2h)

    Guests (only one blogger among representatives of the paper press institution, TV, university and La Cinémathèque) :

    My notes from the collective debate :


    CRISIS OF PAPER PRESS

    Drop of interest by paper readers, and drop of sales, shrinking of the space allocated to cinema in newspapers... the cinema discourse online has built up and solidified in the last 10 years, from the online forums, to the websites of paper publications, to the blogs.

    Blog : Impressions intuitive, subjective, intimate and fetishistic, like a collector album of cinema memories. Cross-references, confrontations, extrapolations... dialogue of cinema with architecture, urbanism, songs, football...
    Multimedia content, using sound and image, a form that is impossible on paper.

    There is the death of something (institutional criticism) and the birth of something else (multimedia criticism), which is very chaotic. Revolution of the "function critic". To break the stream of weekly professional criticism.
    Internet is "the place of diffraction of the critical speech" against the professionalism of the formatted critic profession.


    MULTIMEDIA CRITICISM

    Freedom of the internet opposed to constraint of TV production. Notably the proverbial "fair use" of film clip citations on a blog, which is vetoed by Copyrights bureaucracy on TV programs, or film documentaries (expensive fees!). It opens a liberty of creation, montage, collage and détournement on the web, at least for a few more months until the studios enforce some kind of regulation.
    Possibility to develop a certain film criticism without a voice-over commentary, by means of images alone, with a dialogue of films themselves (e.g. Matthias Muller), home-movies, vlog, as a form of visual criticism.
    Unlimited length. No censor. No editor.

    Links cited during the debate :

    Revue en ligne : Critikat; Ecran Large; Objectif Cinéma; cinema-take;
    Forums : Dvd Classik; DVDrama;
    Blogs : Serge Toubiana; alapoursuiteduvent; La Lanterne; Zohiloff; Matière Focale; Bertrand Tavernier; Compagnon Geek; Ce qui nous regarde;
    Educational sites :
    Lumière!; Quai des images; télédoc; Zéro de conduite;


    Related link:

    18 mars 2011

    Le cinéma par ses praticiens

    Série d'entretiens sur les évolutions du cinéma durant la décennie 2000-2009
    Avec : Lionel Baier (cinéaste, exploitant), Nicolas Klotz (cinéaste), Olivier Lorelle (scénariste), Christie Molia (productrice), Luc Moullet (cinéaste, acteur, critique), Javier Packer-Comyn (directeur artistique 'Cinéma du Réel'), Frédéric Ramade (cinéaste), Claire Simon (cinéaste)

    Par Critikat (Vincent Avenel, Sarah Elkaïm, Laurine Estrade, Arnaud Hée, Alexandre Labarussiat, Mathieu Macheret, Marion Pasquier, Camille Pollas) Montage : Raphaël Lefèvre. Habillage : Alexandre Labarussiat. (27 Janvier 2010)


    Première partie : Voir - Regarder : les films remarquables/représentatifs de la décennie ; l'évolution dans la manière de voir les films (24'12") :


    Deuxième partie : Raconter, représenter : les évolutions/tendances narratives et esthétiques ; les rapports du cinéma à son époque (23'34") :


    Troisième partie : Technologies, écrans : subir/se servir des nouvelles technologies ; la révolution DV ; extension du domaine du cinéma (24'48") :


    Quatrième partie : Economie(s) du cinéma : monter un projet ; les "films du milieu" ; vie des films ; droits d'auteur (28'48") :


    Cinquième partie : Critique et avenir : la critique de cinéma ; géographie du cinéma ; état du cinéma ; le cinéma dans dix ans (25'53") :