14 mai 2011

Mandarins vs Philistines (Bordwell)

"In most arts, academic study isn’t considered the enemy of journalistic criticism. [..] When it comes to cinema, though, the relations are cool, even adversarial."
Academics vs. Critics. Never the twain shall meet: why can't cinephiles and academics just get along? David Bordwell (Film Comment, May 2011) 
He's talking about the climate in the USA of course, which is a particular combination of anti-intellectualism, fear of alienating oneself from the gut reactions of the crowd and the guilty conscience of enjoying cinephilia. American critics have the phobic anxiety to be perceived as "objective" or "intellectual". American scholars have the repressed guilt of infusing their love of cinema into their object of clinical studies. I guess the Grand Theory chiasm is typical to American ambivalence. There is so much useless drama around the repressed subjectivity of film students who want to be accepted in academe through self-important jargon. 
You don't see such extreme polarisation in French culture... There is a gap between common reviewers and actual researchers, each side acknowledges their territory of competency and their incompatibility but they use eachothers and communicate to exchange ideas (even when it fails). In fact French film scholars come from cinephilia (which is something American scholars tend to forget). Delluc, Epstein, Mitry, Desnos, Malraux, Artaud, Blanchot, Debord, Metz, Duras, Lyotard, Foucault, Debord, Deleuze, Bellour, Rancière, Badiou, Nancy are unapologetic cinephiles! French intellectuals are not afraid to admit their cinephilia, or their guilty pleasure, they don't shy away from hermeneutics and evaluation.  
This topic seems to be a recurring concern for Bordwell, and I'm glad because it's worth repeating until the futility of such arguments stops clouding the general film discourse. This is an abstract categorization though. Evaluation and subjectivity might be the casus belli between actual film studies and actual film criticism, but what worries me more is the dissemination and misappropriation of such theoretical arguments into the lowest planes of film discourse. Pseudo-academics and wannabe reviewers appropriate and abuse this conflict, in order to somehow validate their participation to film culture, while they are neither scholars nor critics. It's not because somebody positions oneself in the objective/subjective war that it makes him/her a critic or a scholar. The impression of holding and defending a position replaces for some people the importance of discipline and ideas. What is destroying film culture is the infiltration of posers and other impostors at institutional levels, in the film press, in academic circles... And the main reason is that either nobody pays enough attention to notice the B.S. published everywhere, or, which is worse, that a pervading complacency lets such counterfeit arguments be for the sake of putting out content and mutual friendly encouragements. These types of irresponsible practices make the academic vs. journalist gap seem trivial.

A more pressing issue than the academic vs. cinephile debate to oppose Grand Theory, is to reflect on the nature of their incompatibility. The reason why Semiotics, Reception Studies, Gender Studies, Cultural Studies failed assimilation to Film Culture, is precisely because they deal less with cinema itself than with a broader theory or abstract concepts across general culture in its globality. Semiotics is to cinema what grammar is to Literature, or chromatology to Painting. Reception studies is hardly specific to cinema, and could indifferently apply to Theatre, Literature or Pavlov. Gender studies is a socio-cultural issue, again spanning across all arts and media indifferently. Knowing the building blocks of words (Literature) or colors (Painting) or chords (Music) is important to acquire a general understanding of the technique, but doesn't inform the production of aesthetic meaning resulting from the artist's use of such generic technique.

I see Cultural Studies as being a subset of Sociology, using movies as a statistical sample, on the other hand I see Aesthetics as the only academic studies dealing with what makes cinema an art, treating films as artistic statements. The controversy is whether you consider cinema as an ethnological evidence for the study of mankind or as the contribution to the history of the Arts for the study of Cinema itself. There is no wrong answer, but your slant will make your writing relevant to Cinema or to another domain of interest outside of and larger than cinema (Humanities, Sociology, Economy, Epistemology, Philology...) That's why there is no possible reconciliation. Academics from Cultural Studies are observing ideological phenomena AROUND the consumption of cinema as entertainment, OUTSIDE of the Arts.

You don't understand the place of La Joconde in the Arts by surveying visitors at Le Louvre, observing under the microscope its canvas, or contemplating whether Mona Lisa was a dude... Unfortunately that's how Cultural Studies are treating Cinema, as a commodity consumed by pigeon-holed shares of a demographic.

Bordwell is wondering why there is a gap between cinephiles and academics... I think it is a moot point. If it doesn't take away precious time from the serious study of Great Cinema (classics and contemporary), film scholars may study whatever they fancy! Be it Humanities or Economy or the Star System or Movie posters or trade newspaper or gossips... as long as any of this is NOT put in the same box as Cinema Art, just because it is remotely related to film production. Scholars don't need to seek the approval of auteurists or cinephiles...
That's the real problem today: anybody can write any bullshit about some movies and it will insidiously infiltrate Film Discourse, and sometimes pass as "serious criticism" just because it is a subversive way of looking at a B-movie that everyone else ignored. Turning lowbrow entertainment into highbrow film studies is a very very marginal share of cinema history, it doesn't happen every year! It's not because one blockbuster becomes socially relevant worldwide for a couple months that it has become an instant classic. I wish film discourse (contrary to humanities) had prospects with longer terms than that.

Bordwell: "[..] the auteur tradition never studied in detail how the Hollywood system worked. Suspending evaluation allows us to ask questions that aren't simply factual but have broader implications. The standard story about the early 'evolution of film language' has been shown over the last 30 years to be at best an oversimplification and at worst inadequate. But scholars had to look beyond the few classics of Griffith, Chaplin, and DeMille to what now realize to be a great diversity of creative choice."
The purpose of "Authorism" (or "Auteur Theory") is to look at films (possibly as part of a body of work or œuvre) from the perspective of the film director (most likely scenarist-director). It is self-limited in scope and in its object of study, by definition. It doesn't study ALL films, only those made with the implicit intention to create an œuvre (recurrent theme, trademark style, obsessions, original mise en scène). Not all films fit this criterion, especially not most early films. It is very selective by nature, not only in the titles studied but in the specific, narrow aspects of a larger production. So it seems OBVIOUS why the study of an industrial economical infrastructure like the "Hollywood system" is not part of the "auteur tradition", no? It's like blaming a biographer of Honoré de Balzac for not mentioning once the complete history of Gutenberg's movable type printing... Some academics study the infrastructure, other academics study the art. To each his own job. He said that as if the "auteur tradition" had the responsibility to write the TOTAL HISTORY of cinema (including non-auteurist productions), and failed. This said, I believe that in the 50ies, the so-called "auteur tradition" studied more seriously the "Hollywood system" than any American academics or critics, if only as a starting point for further investigations.
Second point : Isn't it a bit presumptuous for historians to base a comprehensive understanding of the average production of silent cinema on what amounts to 20% of leftovers from that period? About 80% of nitrate prints have been destroyed or lost! At this rate, it's more like archeology based on sparse fossils found in the soil by chance. Do you think we would KNOW about the cinema of the XXIst century if we only watched 20% of the current production? Oh wait, this is about as much of world production (including Hollywood production!) that is actually screened in commercial theatres in the USA...

"The prototypical cinephile piece in effect answers a question like this: “What distinctive qualities of this film can I detect, and how do they enhance our sense of its value?” The prototypical academic interpretation would be answering something like: “What aspects of the film are illuminated by my theoretical frame of reference?” I think, however, that we academics can make progress in understanding cinema if our questions are more specifically and self-consciously formulated." Academics vs. Critics. Never the twain shall meet: why can't cinephiles and academics just get along? David Bordwell (Film Comment, May 2011) 
"Film criticism lies at the centre of nearly all intellectual discourse about the cinema, and if we take criticism to be an effort to know particular movies more intimately, it probably deserves its prime place. But contemporary film criticism is failing. In academic venues, it mostly grinds Movie X through Theory Y, in the hope that somehow the exercise will yield political emancipation." Backpage: Against Insight David Bordwell (cinemascope, #26, 2006)
This sounds great. And then, when he reviews a minimalist, contemplative film he exemplifies himself the very shortcomings he criticizes Academia for : inadequately grinding random films through his classic theories of transitions with a film like What Time Is It There? (David Bordwell, The Hook: Scene Transitions in Classical Cinema, January 2008), or his classic theories of editing with a film like The Shaft (Three from Palm Springs, 16 Jan 2009), or his classic theories of staging for an undefined "slow cinema" (The Cross, David Bordwell, 1 June 2010) or his classic theories of suspense with a film like Le Quattro Volte (No suspense? David Bordwell, 11 April 2011; see my comment here), instead of adapting to what the specific stylistic of the film requires, and trying to understand what distinguishes classic narratives from minimalist narratives. What is the point of knowing so much about Cinema History if it's to treat recent films as if they had been made 70 years ago?

"Less obvious is the overlap between cinephile criticism and what I’d call middle-level research." David Bordwell (Film Comment, May 2011) 
More on "middle-level research" if you read his 1996 book :

"This 'middle-level' research asks questions that have both empirical and theoretical import. That is, and contrary to many expositors of Grand Theory, being empirical does not rule out being theoretical.
The most established realms of middle-level research have been empirical studies of filmmakers, genres, and national cinemas. [..]" Post Theory, reconstructing film studies (Carroll/Bordwell, 1996)


Hopeful parting thought:
"Academics have more elbow room to study how those qualities came into being, how they work together, and what roles they play historically and culturally. Academics can also contribute new ideas that critics on the front lines can try out. Readers who enjoy cinephile criticism should sample the academic work that stays close to the sensuous surface of a movie. Meanwhile, academics should recognize how cinephile criticism can alert us to the movie’s unique identity. Perceptive appreciation and analytical explanation can enhance one another."
Amen.



Related:

50 SiC

50ème anniversaire de la Semaine de la Critique (Festival de Cannes)
écoutez : Projection Privée, Michel Ciment (France Culture, 14 mai 2011) 59' [MP3]
avec:
  • Jean-Jacques Bernard (journaliste et réalisateur, Président du Syndicat Français de la Critique de Cinéma et de télévision),
  • Jean-Christophe Berjon (délégué général de la Semaine Internationale de la Critique) et
  • Charles Tesson (critique et historien du cinéma)
Jean-Jacques Bernard: "C'est une concurrence et une stimulation [avec la selection officielle de Cannes]. noublions pas que si le festival de Cannes n'existait pas dans son ampleur, dans sa magesté - premier festival du monde - la Semaine de la Critique n'aurait pas cet éclat. C'est parce qu'il y a un grand festival ici qu'il y a une grande semaine de la critique. L'un et l'autre s'adossent constament."

Quelques découvertes des premiers films selectionnés par la SiC :
  • Jacques Rozier (Adieu Philippine, 1962)
  • Chris Marker (Le Joli mai, 1963)
  • Denys Arcand (Seul ou avec d’autres, 1963 et La Maudite galette, 1972)
  • Bernardo Bertolucci (Prima della revoluzione, 1964)
  • Jerzy Skolimowski (Walkover, 1965)
  • Dusan Makavejev (Man is not a Bird, 1966 and Love Affair, 1967)
  • Jean Eustache (Le Père Noël a les yeux bleus, 1966 et La Rosière de Pessac, 1969)
  • Jean-Marie Straub (Nicht Versöhnt / Non réconcilié, 1966 et Chronique d’Anna Magdalena Bach, 1968)
  • Ousmane Sembene (La Noire de…, 1966)
  • Robert Kramer (En marge, 1968 et Ice, 1970)
  • Otar Iosseliani (La Chute des feuilles, 1968)
  • Philippe Garel (Marie pour mémoire, 1968)
  • Fernando Solanas (L’Heure des brasiers, 1969)
  • Barbet Schroeder (More, 1969)
  • Alain Tanner (Charles mort ou vif, 1969)
  • Ken Loach (Kes, 1970)
  • Paul Morrissey (Trash, 1971)
  • Victor Erice (The Spirit of the Beehive, 1974)
  • Benoît Jacquot (L’Assassin musicien, 1975)
  • John Sayles (Liana, 1983)
  • Leos Carax (Boy Meets Girl, 1984)
  • Amos Gitai (Esther, 1986)
  • Idrissa Ouedraogo (The Choice, 1987)
  • Tran-Anh Hung (La Femme mariée de Nam Xuong, 1989 CM)
  • Wong Kar-Wai (As Tears Go By, 1989)
  • Arnaud Desplechin (La Vie des morts, 1991)
  • Benoît Poelvoorde, Rémy Belvaux et André Bonzel (C’est arrivé près de chez vous, 1992)
  • Guillermo del Toro (Cronos, 1993)
  • Jacques Audiard (Regarde les hommes tomber, 1994)
  • Kevin Smith (Clerks, 1994)
  • Andrea Arnold (Milk, 1998 CM)
  • François Ozon (Une Robe d’été, 1996 CM et Sitcom, 1998)
  • Gaspar Noé (Carne, 1991 CM et Seul contre tous, 1998)
  • Alejandro González Iñárritu (Amores perros, 2000)
  • Neil Jordan (Not I, 2000 CM)
  • Bertrand Bonello (Le Pornographe, 2001)
  • Bill Plympton (Eat, 2001 CM)
  • Miranda July (Me and You and Everyone We Know, 2005)
  • Arturo Ripstein (Los Heroes y el tiempo, 2005)

La Semaine de La Critique célèbre sa 50e édition lors du prochain Festival de Cannes. Pour célébrer cet anniversaire, la Semaine, qui se consacre depuis ses débuts en 1962 à la découverte de nouveaux talents en présentant des premières et secondes œuvres du monde entier, met à l’honneur les personnalités qu’elle a révélées. Avec ces témoignages filmés, la Semaine rend hommage aux réalisateurs et comédiens ayant débuté dans cette section en partageant les souvenirs de 50 ans de premières fois cannoises. Ces vidéos, réalisées par un journaliste critique ou par les cinéastes eux-mêmes, donnent la parole aux réalisateurs.
Abel & Gordon; Hany Abu-Assad; Karin Albou; Marie Amachoukeli; Jacques Audiard; Aida Begic; Alain Bergala; Bernardo Bertolucci; Julie Bertuccelli; Christoffer Boe; Bertrand Bonello; Claire Burger; Adrian Caetano; Grégoire Colin; Carlos Diegues; Jean-Pierre Daroussin; Guillermo del Toro; Anaïs Demoustier; Fabrice du Welz; Claude Duty; Inès Efron; Patrik Eklund; Pablo Fendrik; Esmir Filho; Marina Foïs; Anne Fontaine; James Franco; Shira Geffen; Amos Gitaï; Arturo Goetz; Alejandro Gonzales Iñarritu; Romain Goupil; Otar Iosselani; Benoît Jacquot; Thierry Jousse; Anna KArina; Marin Karmitz; Etgar Keret; Agnes Kocsis; Lee Chang-dong; Pierre Lhomme; Jean-Pierre Limosin; Ken Loach; Paul Morrissey; Greg Mottola; Johannes Stjärne Nilsson; Anna Novion; Martin Piroyansky; Lucia Puenzo; Jacques Rozier; Nicolas Saada; John Sayles; Alo Simonsson; Fernando Solanas; Judith Henry; Keren Yedaya.



* * *

Reprise des 7 films en competition à la Semaine de la Critique à Paris (La Cinémathèque Française) du 3 au 6 juin 2011.

Related:

11 mai 2011

Cahiers-Cannes

Stéphane Delorme : "[..] le Festival est devenu le rendez-vous absolu à la fois des meilleurs films et de l'industrie, une suprématie qui ne va qu'en s'accentuant. [..] Mais combien de films seront écrabouillés dans l'étau entre septembre et novembre ? On doute fort qu'un effet « rentrée littéraire » soit favorable à la distribution. [..]  Embargo sur la compétition [..] Les Cahiers se retrouvent donc à se caler sur le rythme précis imposé pour Cannes. [..] L'an prochain, faudra-t-il refaire un dossier spécial ? La question se pose. Peut-être, si des gros films se jettent à l'eau en mai et que les plus petits envisagent le coup de pouce de la revue à l'approche de Cannes. Le lecteur des Cahiers ne descend pas forcément sur la Croisette (les distributeurs ont tendance à l'oublier) et est friand en amont d'informations, de textes, de photos pour suivre le Festival. [..]  Parce que ce ne sont pas des films Cahiers ? Mais cela fait trente ans que les Cahiers défendent Craven, et quinze ans les Farrelly ! Que ce soit à cause de la négligence, du mépris, ou de la peur de la presse, il devient difficile de faire un mensuel."
Pas étalonné! Editorial Cahiers, n°667 (mai 2011)
Contrairement à ses homologues anglophones, Delorme a la sagesse de reconnaitre l'importance de Cannes, et ne pas tomber dans la mesquine polémique des "cinéphiles" snobinards qui prennent un malin plaisir à rouler dans la boue les festivals majeurs qui font vivre la planète cinéma.
En critique consciencieux, il s'interroge sur les difficultés de la distribution des films de la sélection cannoise. Moins sortent en mai, en synchronicité avec la projection pour les critiques. Et plus sortent en septembre-octobre, dans un embouteillage infernal. Au moins, on devrait s'en réjouir, ils sortent en salles pour le grand public en France, ce qui n'est pas le cas outre-atlantique! 
Ensuite, il se plaint de ne pouvoir révéler le nom des films avant tout le monde, et de publier des résumés pour les films en première mondiale, début mai, avant que quiconque ne soit arrivé à Cannes.

Je crois qu'il oublie que Cannes n'est pas un festival franco-français dont les Cahiers serait une sorte d'attaché de presse... Si Delorme s'oppose à l'effet de surprise d'une première mondiale, le prestige d'un grand festival comme Cannes issu du principe d'exclusivité n'a plus lieu d'être! En fait, il rechigne à voir les films en même temps que tous les autres critiques mondiaux, avec ses insinuations de chantage affectif (y'aura pas de dossier l'an prochain... nanana nanère). Soit on accepte les règles du jeu de l'embargo, pour faire de Cannes un moment unique qui n'est pas pré-digéré à l'avance dans la presse. Soit on abandonne l'idée d'avoir en France un festival qui compte dans le monde. Etant donné le pôle magnétique qu'est devenu Cannes, les desiderata des Cahiers importent peu sur les décisions de Jacob et Frémaux.
Je trouve tout à fait normal de ne pas lire dans le numéro de mai, les synopsis de tous les films qui doivent conserver leur mystère, non seulement avant l'ouverture de Cannes, mais aussi jusqu'au jour de leur projection. Sinon ça n'a aucun sens de faire attendre certains réalisateurs jusqu'au dernier jour du festival pour projeter leur film après tous les autres. Ils acceptent d'attendre parce que les critiques continue d'anticiper jusqu'à la première officielle. Et si le prix à payer est de prolonger la frustration des lecteurs, qu'il en soit ainsi. 

La couverture d'un festival ne devrait pas être envisagée comme n'importe quelle semaine de l'année, dont les films en distributions sont annoncés et décryptés avant même d'apparaître sur les écrans. La compétition de Cannes c'est pas les sorties en salles de la semaine.

Les lecteurs seraient surement plus content de pouvoir lire les réactions des Cahiers avant le numéro de Juin! Mais on ne peut pas satisfaire tous leurs désirs égoïstes, ni ceux des mensuels... Un festival ça se dévoile au jour le jour, et si les mensuels sont incapable de suivre le rythmes des nouvelles technologies, tant pis pour eux! C'est pas aux festivals de s'adapter à la presse papier du XXe siècle.
Burdeau avait tenté un moment d'établir un contact en direct de Cannes via le site web des Cahiers, avec chat et billets journaliers. Mais, Delorme a réduit à néant cette interface web : plus de chat, plus de forum, plus de contenu web hors-issue... Ce n'est pas à Cannes à s'adapter à la presse papier, ce sont aux mensuels à s'adapter au XXIe siècle!

A défaut de pouvoir tout savoir sur les films de la sélection, peut-être serait-il bienvenue pour un mensuel d'imaginer une manière différente de participer au festival, sans en gâcher le plaisir. Soit en se détachant du format mensuel pour l'occasion, en usant de moyens plus interactifs. Soit en proposant autre chose qu'une liste de synopsis, en parlant d'autre chose que d'actualité qui n'a pas encore eu lieu. Il faut parler avec des acteurs décisifs du cinéma mondial, faire un bilan de la distribution de l'ancienne sélection, la carrière des lauréats dans leur pays respectif, en France et dans le monde. Reprendre l'excellente idée de Tesson/Frodon pour un Atlas mondial du cinéma (annuel), l'occasion de prendre contact avec des critiques étrangers qui décrivent l'état de leur marché national, de comparer l'évolution des goûts aux quatre coin du monde.
Et puis repousser à juin, le numéros spécial Cannes, avec des papiers plus posés, moins bâclés, sur chaque film, sur les sections parallèles. Un numéro sur Cannes écrit et publié APRES Cannes, est plus crédible qu'un mois avant l'ouverture du festival! Même si il arrive 2 semaine après tous les quotidiens. Mais il faut choisir entre le presse de l'immédiat, et la presse au temps long des mensuels qui s'attardent sur les sujets pour les approfondir. L'opinion des Cahiers devrait garder tout son intérêt même si on a déjà lu l'opinion superficiel des journaux et du web, surtout si les lecteurs ne peuvent voir les films qu'à la rentrée. C'est aux Cahiers de se faire attendre, plutôt que compter sur l'unique avantage d'avoir parler avant les autres.

Cannes est un moment exceptionnel dans l'année, une seule fois par an. Les films présentés se précipitent pour être vu là-bas des professionnels. Mais ce n'est pas la date de Cannes qui définit quand sortent les films commercialement. On ne peut pas avoir tous les meilleurs films de l'année sortis dans la même semaine sous prétexte que les critiques les ont déjà vus. Le temps des professionnels et le temps du grand public ne coïncident pas. 

Ce n'est pas la première fois que les Cahiers se plaignent de n'avoir pas accès aux films de genre commerciaux (selon le cliché que ce ne sont pas des "films-Cahiers"). Burdeau, fan d'Hollywood, avait déjà réclamé qu'on lui paie le voyage pour avoir accès à des junkets à L.A. Quelle misère d'en arriver là... quémander à Hollywood ce que même les journalistes de l'entertainment devrait refuser par déontologie professionnelle. Ça ne grandit pas la critique cinéma.
Ainsi, Delorme explique que les Cahiers défendent Craven depuis 30 ans et Farrelly depuis 15 ans. Si cela avait un impact sur les ventes d'Hollywood... ils vous harcèleraient sans répit. Pas la peine de jouer au lèche-cul. Ce que cet aveu implique est plutôt malsain : si Craven et Farrelly ont "la carte", qu'il on reçu le "label Cahiers" pour leur films précédents, vous promettez donc de publier une critique positive pour leur nouveau film sans l'avoir vu??? Ça craint quand même une mentalité pareille. Pourquoi est-ce qu'ils devraient vous faire confiance à l'aveugle? Et d'ailleurs, interdire les projection de presse dans la crainte d'un mauvais papier est contraire aux règles. S'il suffisait de montrer le films aux critiques qui adorent, la vie serait tellement simple pour les studios qui aiment faire des navets. 


Si les exclusivité vous est soufflé par Twitter, et que vous êtes obligés de voir les films en salles (comme tout le monde, quelle horreur!)... il va bien falloir faire une sérieuse introspection et repenser le rôle de la presse à une époque où tout lecteur est connecté au web en permanence et n'attend pas un mois pour connaitre les moindres infos dont la presse avait jadis le monopole. 
Regardez de l'avant. Les nouvelles technologies ne vont pas ralentir pour vous faciliter la tâche.



Lire aussi :


10 mai 2011

Clueless anti-festival clichés

"Here follows a number of current clichés about the film business:
  • Film festivals are a massive growth industry [..]
  • Film festivals are now a crucial part of modern independent (and especially foreign-language) film business [..]
  • Film festivals now constitute an alternative "distribution network" [..]
  • Film festivals are about discovery, revealing to the world films that the existing distribution mechanisms fail to reach [..]
Let's just, for the sake of balance, shade a little reality into some of the clichés:
  • New film festivals are indeed springing up all the time, particularly in North America [..] All film festivals rely on 3 revenue sources - ticket sales, public money and sponsorship
  • All film festivals rely [..] on a number of poorly paid short-term staff [..] unpaid volunteers
  • Film festivals may be an alternative distribution network for a certain type of film, but one entirely devoid of a business model: apart from the occasional screening fee [..] no money is generated for the film's maker. Tickets revenue goes to the festival
  • There are not nearly enough good films to go around [..]
[..] it is the excessive top-down structure of the film distribution system : [..] we see what films Warners or Paramount [..], when [..] and for as long as they decide we should see them."

"Big society, little clue", Nick Roddick (Sight and Sound, May 2011)

Finally an ounce of pertinence in the pages of Sight and Sound, taking a hard look at the spoon-fed system that gives the film press its only reason to carry on. If you didn't review "all films of the month", in a servile manner, the ones approved by the official distribution system... maybe this magazine would have the legitimacy to criticize the festival circuit and the state of cinema in the world. Nonetheless, this is a good baby-step in the right direction.  

Film Festivals are no more an "industry" than international car shows... it's a place to show your products and sell the rights to export them. The commercialization (the part where you sell cars to consumers) takes places afterwards, once the distributors have negotiated their contract, bought the stock and exhibit the commercial products to the public. The car shows or the film festivals do not make benefits at this point, marginal sales are insignificant  to the expected gross revenue (that shall refund the production cost). 1 or 2 screenings at a festival (500 or 2000 admissions) does not pay back the production cost of a feature film!!! The film festival circuit is located outside of the commercial circuit, upstreams from the actual commercialization. Even the festival cuts of the film are sometimes different from the final official cut, precisely because it's merely a screening destined to professionals only, fresh from the editing room, and sometimes barely finalized.

If certain films (non-commercial films, challenging artfilms, niche audience offerings...) are only allowed to meet an audience (of regular public spectators), on the "festival circuit", 1 screening at the time, they are never going to make profits. Not only it is not a viable alternative to the commercial exhibition, but it is not an acceptable ghettoization. All narrative films, whatever their format or content or style, should be treated equally by the distribution circuit, meaning that they should have at least access to a public release. Films cannot be relegated to back alleys just because they are considered "non-profitable" or "intellectual". The popularity of "blockbusters" will influence the number of screens allocated of course. There is no point in having a mass audience locked out of full theatres because there are screens showing non-commercials films to an empty auditorium... But the other extreme is equally stupid, and that is the situation we are in now : artfilms are not even slated for public distribution (or eventually on a single screen nationwide!) just because the marketing predictions estimate that the audience doesn't like artfilms. 

There must be a reasonable number of screens (or show time slots during the week) dedicated to NON-COMMERCIAL cinema, because even if few people at the time wants to watch them (and it takes more than a week-end for the artfilm word of mouth to succeed) the access to the public must be guaranteed by law. It is too easy for distributors to purchase cheap artfilm distribution rights in the sole intention to shelf them ad infinitum (keeping them off the market, where risk-taking distributors would try to buy them). Money can't buy your competition like that. Or else the richest studios would lose less money by holding up their direct competition, than by having to market their films against too many alternative choices. In the USA, money buys everything, even the silence of the artfilm culture. And American critics find this situation perfectly fine... I don't care if American audiences refuse to watch (better) artfilms / foreign films, because their taste has been formated by Hollywood standards of mediocrity. The role of film critics and the film industry is to respect all films and give them all a decent chance!  

All this isn't the fault of a growing festival circuit! All this does is to develop the professional network to exchange distribution rights, not only globally at the few major festivals, but also locally at every local festival, relaying the discoveries made by major festivals on the other side of the planet. International buyers can afford to travel to Cannes, Venice or Berlin every year. But the local arthouse exhibitors (who are not part of a mainstream franchise) need the existence of local festivals at their level, within their reach, to discover themselves the non-commercial titles they will want to invest in, take a chance to support and sell to their local regular spectators. The commercial profits of artfilms shall be made in commercial arthouses, not on the festival circuit. Art films are not made for the unique privileged festival-goer audience (the cinephile jet-set)! Art films are made to reach out to every city and villages, even if it's only 1 screening a week, and if it takes 3 or 5 years after it's world premiere. Unfortunately, it is impossible to watch them currently if you don't live in a state capital, or a cinephile city, because art films are not marketed elsewhere, and art filmmakers cannot make a living based on one-off screenings, unpaid festival screenings, direct to DVD distribution, and illegal downloads. Hollywood loses peanuts with illegal downloads, but art filmmakers lose a much larger share of their total sales (which is, at the same time, significantly lower than the average Hollywood flick's revenue). They lose a larger percentage of a smaller total. 

Art filmmakers are not making films for the sport, to be watched by critics who don't even pay admission fees. The job of serious critics is to convince readers that challenging films are worth begging for, by inciting to harass lazy distributors until they give artfilms a dignified release! 


Related:

06 mai 2011

Random Factoid 3: Festival sizes

To those who think that festivals grow exponentially every year, out of control... you can see that the number of films selected in competition in the Cannes International Film Festival, since 1994, didn't vary much. (see PDF here for details). The official competition where nominees are eligible for La Palme d'Or, just like the parallel section, Un Certain Regard, have always been between 19 and 24; both 20 this year. La Semaine de la Critique didn't change its format, always 1 feature film per day : 7 in total (plus a handful of special screenings). La Quinzaine des Réalisateurs has fluctuated without regularity from 15 to 25, with a peak at 30 in 2003. La Cinéfondation supports 13 to 20 debuting filmmakers each year, since 1998.
Only the Off Competition screenings have increased steadily, from only 3 in 1994 to 23 in 2006... 19 this year.

In total the various competitions (Official, Regard, Quinzaine, SiC) amount in 2011 to 68 mandatory feature film viewing, plus the short films. The rest are promotional screenings. With 6 screenings a day, in 10 days, a dedicated critic could watch at least 60 films during the course of the festival (without counting the few advance-screenings for the press, ahead of the festival). And since the coverage of a festival by a film magazine or a newspaper is never a one-man show, 2 or 3 well organised critics could easily watch the complete selection (including the often neglected parallel sections!), plus snoop around for some unexpected gems in the promotional screenings and the marketplace. The task is easily manageable. I don't understand why certain critics dare to complain. World cinema is not defined by the maximum capacity of a single man to watch films within 10 days (especially when they crash celebrity parties instead of doing their job!)
Number of films in Cannes (1994-2011) Official selection
The only notable expension of the Cannes event, is actually a side show that is not an integer part of the Film Festival : Le Marché du Film; which doubled in size since 1994 (435 projects for sale), reaching a peak in 2008 (1004 projects). 876 films last year. But this part of the event is reserved for buyers (and the press), and is only there to benefit from the media coverage energized by the festival competition and the presence of red carpet galas!
The films selected in competition are the cream of the crop, at world-class level for the current year, these are the films critics must see and review. But critics don't need to watch all (if any) of the projects (often unfinished or not even started) promoted on the marketplace. So these should not count in the survey of the festival evolution. Most of these projects are not even great in the first place... it could easily be the commercial fare, at a mediocre level. If producers can afford to showcase a bad film in Cannes, nothing prevents it. While the Cannes competition is a serious process of selection from the best filmmakers in the world. Not necessarily the very best of the year (some may surface in Venice or Berlin), and sometimes films are invited for their original or risky aesthetics even if they don't measure up to the world's top tier. But the selection is artistically sound, contrary to the marketplace.

Do not mistake the marketplace event (commercial business) with the Festival competition (non-commercial celebration of art cinema). 
Number of films at the marketplace (Cannes 1994-2010)

Related:

02 mai 2011

Voluntary Engineered Apathy

Implicit Comfort Zone (defined by the system)

Eli Pariser: Beware online "filter bubbles" (TED talk, March 2011) 9'05"
As web companies strive to tailor their services (including news and search results) to our personal tastes, there's a dangerous unintended consequence: We get trapped in a "filter bubble" and don't get exposed to information that could challenge or broaden our worldview. Eli Pariser argues powerfully that this will ultimately prove to be bad for us and bad for democracy.

* * *
  1. We acquire predictable habits by living in a self-alimented sphere (Closed distribution market)
  2. The system observes our habits, and defines a taste profile for us ("you might also like this")
  3. We consume the proposed choices and reinforce the taste pattern (Avoiding to be exposed to alterity)
  4. Our engineered consumption, observed by the system again after recommendations, comforts the system's predictions (Proving the system right)
All it takes is for consumers to be lazy enough, not to seek out new films by themselves, the ones hard to get hold of immediately, and a minimal satisfaction from the movies suggested by the system, to make us believe in the miracle of the taste pattern prediction.

"People who bought this DVD, also bought these" Why would I want to watch everything my neighbours (or the control group who picked the same movie as me) did? This assumes that people are not individuals but predictable robots. Also, it means that movies are not unique, but neatly fit into a statistical box where the same demographic will come back to feed regularly like butterfly answering the call of pheromones...
Who said people who watch a type of movie would always want to rewatch the same type of movies? Statistics on the average consumer maybe... Open minded people with a normal dose of cultural curiosity, like to discover things that escape their usual diet, to be surprised, shocked, startled, challenged, transformed. Unfortunately we move towards a standardized universe that suits all too well the industries that produce a limited number of cultural goods, one-size-fits-all, mass produced for optimal cost. The Long Tail Consumption (the peer to peer exchange) is the nightmare of big corporations that can't count in small numbers. 
If you live in a country where the titles of films available for distribution are predefined by overarching marketing strategies whose interest is to boost local economy (i.e. the titles/remakes offered by their national studio), chances are that you don't know what you're missing. The apparent plethora of titles distributed every week keeps consumers busy with pointless choices between half-good and mediocre (deceptive free will). Meanwhile they don't worry about the actually great films they are missing. Because this involves effort to think outside the box and go get the informations by yourself. Moreover, being subject to this cultural isolationism and conditioning, since an early age (as the entire society is built upon these systems of predetermined options) shapes up an even more predictable taste pattern, one that will make you feel repulsed by alternative choices or challenging tastes, should you ever stumble upon them by accident. Just like babies fed with sweets refuse to eat spinach. Demanding what "feels rewarding immediately" is not always the best option for your long term intellectual development. You have to eat spinach! But you don't know it, and it doesn't feel right. But it's not because it's harder than you should always go for the easy choice that feels like hitting home. These systems of taste patterns are treating movie goers like babies, constantly feeding them what they want, and not what is good for a healthy culture and a sensibility to alterity. Infantilization of the masses. And since the mass is happy with it... nobody cares to ask for alternative choices. 

Critics can not walk into the system without any critical distance with its consequences, conveniently locked on the railtracks of the industrial optimisation of consumer goods. You can't behave like any other consumer, blissfully happy with the tailored choices delivered to your doorsteps, like as many trees hiding the forest that distributors do not want you to peek into, because it's more trouble and less profit for them to inject these in the system. Not to mention that inserting alternative choices in the system will screw up the predetermined taste patterns.

Don't think you escape the "filter bubble" because you don't rely on the multiplexes to watch movies... These filters are everywhere, investors decisions or online algorithms, at every level of the distribution system. And the most efficient ones are located at the root : keeping artists from making films in the first place, so their creation is not even surveyed as a potential choice excluded by the system. 


  • "Most popular articles" are what people who want to know what everyone else knows go for
  • "Most viewed videos" will be viewed even more (snowballing traffic)
  • "Favourited by most people" (approved by the mass)
  • "Trending news" is signaled as a hot topic to become hotter (this is what you should be interested in because everyone else is)
  • "Most subscribed" outlets will continue to get best exposition (and upstage everything else)
  • "Most followers" because alternative channels work like mainstream media (widest appeal = highest authority)

And the content available in the film criticism community is funneled through the same sort of filters and standardisations. Critics read critics who read critics. Knowledge keeps circulating inside a closed circuit, amongsts the same people who think alike. They keep exchanging informations coming from the same sources, allowed by the distribution system (Studios public relation talking points, Google/Facebook algorithm, clique forums, syndicated news, RSS feeds, Tweeter circular self-feeding) and the institutional media (paper press tradition, limited translations, outdated canons, stereotypical reviews, conservative taste, low ambition, anti-intellectualism). Linkage galore and Tweets only transmit what publicists intend to publish and reviews of available material. Either the titles excluded by the system are totally ignored, deemed inexistent, or their rare and awkward mention amidst the flow of "official zeitgeist" feels out of place to the conditioned readers who don't know what to do with them.

Think about it : everything you write about, you got it from pre-existing channels of official informations, and you're only able to reflect in a limited number of ways about a limited quantity of informations pre-approved by the system. A critic can not rely on a pre-packaged series of information without questioning where they come from, what infrastructure allowed them to come to you, and what absent informations are missing, blocked off by that system. Critics need to take a look at the big picture to figure out by themselves what is the selection of pertinent information they would like to highlight, without being spoon-fed by a frame of mind (intentional propaganda or mindless automatization).

Critics think by themselves. 

* * *

The antidote to apathy (engagement)
TED talk : Toronto 2010, Dave Meslin, Oct 2010, 7'
Local politics -- schools, zoning, council elections -- hit us where we live. So why don't more of us actually get involved? Is it apathy? Dave Meslin identifies 7 barriers that keep us from taking part in our communities, even when we truly care. Multi-partisan and fiercely optimistic, Dave Meslin embraces ideas and projects that cut across traditional boundaries between grassroots politics, electoral politics and the arts community. 
Leadership is about :
  1. Collective effort (engagement of a whole community, each at their level/capacity)
  2. Imperfect (not glamourous, doesn't suddenly start/stop, lifelong ongoing process)
  3. Voluntary (no hero-messiah prophecy)

Related:

French Critics Legacy 3

Jason Solomon: "My cinematic education happened in Paris. I spent a year there, ostensibly teaching English, but really sneaking off in the afternoon in tiny little cinemas on the Left Bank or in the dingy depths of Les Halles to catch a repertory classic every afternoon. It helped me build up a picture of cinema history, from B-movie westerns to French  New Wave, to Jean Renoir and Film Noir. I couldn't have done that in any other city in the world. So France in undoubtedly the most cinephilic culture. But does that mean they make the best films?
They certainly have the best film festival in the world : Cannes obsesses the whole nation for 2 weeks every May. By contrast the London Film Festival barely interest anyone outside Soho, and on its opening night."
Thanks for paying homage to the educational value of Paris' film culture, sincerely, without being pressured at gunpoint.
The popularity of Cannes in France might be a little over-exaggerated... The tennis tournament Roland-Garros  is always overlapping, and that is the event that captures the audience majority in France. This said, I would be surprised if a film festival in another country does gather a broader attention, on TV, in the Press, in the street buzz, in the couple weeks leading up to Cannes, during the event, and with its awards. Precisely because cinema is historically part of French culture, unlike anywhere else in the world. Anybody knowing about film history knows this is not a chauvinist statement.
I don't see this as bragging rights or a competition. Sadly, a lot of "cinephiles" in the world are bitter about this, and display jealous reactions (either by suppressing French culture or by dissing it), when they are not in total denial (believing cinema culture in their country is not subdued by the industry).
I would like every country in the world to reach the level of familiarity with cinema developed within French culture. Wouldn't it be a better world for cinéphiles if France wasn't the only haven that combines popular support, governmental support, industrial support, artistic support, intellectual support? I don't see why this cannot happen, with a little effort.

Bertrand Tavernier: "I think British politicians have never been preoccupied with cinema. They never fought [for] culture, never saw that culture was important, except people like Winston Churchill, who was more educated than most of the politicians now. He was a brilliant writer and he understood the tremendous importance of cinema to sell your own culture, to sell your own values, to sell your products. [..] You need another Winston Churchill. You need another politician who seem to have read a few books."    
Well, the BFI [EDIT:UK Film council] budget has been cut down by the current government, and when Sight and Sound did a "special issue" on British cinema that very month (summer 2010), Nick James, editor in chief of the BFI magazine, no less, had no clue it was going to happen... That's how you realize it's a long way to sustainability. S&S promised changes (starting by cutting down the fat: credit rolls in reviews! lol) so maybe, the content will be more discerning in the future...

Jason Solomon: "Those French do have a knack for damning with faint praise, don't they? But do they feel their cinema really is superior to ours? I heard many answers to this rather blunt question, and invariably most responses involve two names: Ken Loach and Mike Leigh."
He forgets Stephen Frears, who is named by his interviewees too. These are the 3 famous names amongst most French movie goers with limited British culture. 
I would add Paul Greengrass, Steve MacQueen, Michael Winterbottom, Peter Watkins, Terence Davies... who are consistently high praised by the French press when a movie is released here. And they are familiar to cinéphiles. Don't be so hard on yourself. Tavernier only liked the 50ies, but there were great British films in recent years. Although, with a little over a 100 films produced a year, it's not Hollywood (nearly 600) or France (230)... Industry-wise, there is a concrete gap.

But if we talk about quality, I'm not one who will defend contemporary French cinema. Comparing to the UK is unfair (there are more "big names" in French cinema, so by sheer numbers alone...). But in absolute, within world class standards, I don't think it's at the top, where it once was. It is solid and consistent in above-mediocre quality, like Hollywood, like the UK, like most major cinema nations in the world, but we haven't seen exceptionally outstanding films recently. Smaller countries, especially in Asia or South America are making better movies than us, and for some years now. The petty bickering of the love-hate "Entente cordiale", ignited by Truffaut's remark, doesn't mean much in the big picture of world cinema.

When you ask French guests who came to promote an all-French festival in London, you don't really expect them to tell the local press they think British cinema sucks and that French cinema is superior, do you? Just like when Hollywood celebrities visit Paris, they say on TV they love France to arouse the audience... even though they don't care.
And frankly, I think the interviewees handled this "question provocatrice" quite well, by refusing to make blanket statements, generalisations, about "British cinema" as a unity, and acknowledging that we only see the British cream of the crop released in France. They are not pandering to the British audience either, with fake enthusiastic hyperboles or over-flattering praise. 

Jason Solomon: "So Ozon points to a British snobbery around theatre and film. But after agreeing with him, it's hard not to gaze across the Channel and envy their national pride and political support for the art of cinema. But political and financial help only add up to so much. In the end, French cinema, like any thriving cinema culture, lives and dies on new ideas. [..] My gut instinct is that British cinema in its current state of flux could learn a lot about loving film from our French rivals and neighbours."
True. And that's all we should talk about. Ideas. Not about national pride contests.  
Well, I know what the "new idea" implies... We shouldn't take that as a rush towards novelty. I don't care if auteurs repeat themselves. Art is not about finding new stuff for novelty sake, just to do something that others haven't done before... Cinema is a narrative art and true inventions in dramatic structures or content doesn't happen every year. So reviewers should not expect auteurs to trash their past œuvre at every new film they make, to change their style, their obsessions, their themes... just to surprise critics or festivals. This is not a game show. Aesthetic evolutions are slower and less ostentatious than what attention-deficit commentators would like it to be. 

Source:
  • Jason Solomon (Film Weekly, The Guardian, 25 March 2011) 31'19" [MP3] 



Related:

30 avril 2011

French Critics Legacy 2

Contrary to Bordwell's unfortunate oblivion (French Critics Legacy 1), Jonathan Rosenbaum remembers that French critics inspired the American critics of the 60ies to start appreciating American cinema in a different way : 
Rosenbaum : "I have to say that my appreciation of American cinema came to a large extent from the French. It was French critics who taught me how to appreciate Alfred Hitchcock and Howard Hawks and Nicolas Ray and Samuel Fuller and lots of people. There were some American disciples like Andrew Sarris, but even he was getting a lot of his inspiration from the French. [..] It happens in more than just in films. In literature, William Faulkner was appreciated in France, to a greater extent before it was appreciated in the USA. [..] In America there is a big difference between people who ever left the country even briefly, and just what it does to your perspective, to be able to see America the way the rest of the world sees America. And also to feel that you're part of that world. It's very important to me whether people regard themselves as just citizen of America or whether there're really a citizen of the world, and therefore how much they relate to other people, the international community. And the funny thing is that America is in some ways more isolated now that it was during the Cold War. And yet, because of the internet, the possibilities of being in touch with people all over the world are enormously greater than it were. [..]"
Jonathan Rosenbaum interview (The Marketplace of Ideas, 20 Feb 2011) 57'34" [MP3]    
Eureka! It is much better when an American (an influential figure like Rosenbaum) says it, in the USA, to an American audience. Because nobody listens to the French guy (promptly labeled anti-American) who says the same thing on this very blog. Now, keep repeating this until it is no longer a controversial, anti-American thing to say, and that Americans are past the denial stage, ready to deal with the isolationism of the American culture. It is up to Americans themselves (helped by cultural educators) to work on it, and make their own cultural environment as open to the world as they would like it to be! Educators need to care for this pernicious issue. Students, readers, spectators... need to learn to care for world culture too (against the national-centric interests conveniently imposed by the American market which prefers to sell Hollywood products than to contribute to make a living for foreign artists!). If cinéphiles aren't offended by this situation, are they cinéphiles?

Rosenbaum : "French cinephilia while it's very intense... French culture is in some ways paradoxical, in its own way is kind of insular. Most French film critics I know don't read that much of critics from other cultures. Few of them do, when some things get translated. But to a large extent they read other French critics."
OK. I agree. More than the proverbial language barrier, it's about the self-alimentation of the press community, anywhere it is. And I'd be particularly interested to read a comprehensive survey on available translations in each language, comparatively! Should we compare head-to-head the French-English and English-French translations on either side of the Atlantic? Should we survey what names critics working in the press can cite? what foreign books did they read?

Now before we do that... you're assuming that French criticism would learn something from the American press? I've read the reviews in the NYT, in LAT, in Village Voice, in Cineaste, in Filmmaker, in Artforum, on Salon, on Slate... and I've given up. Maybe the anti-intellectual demographics in America is impressed, I'm not. At least the French press, however imperfect it is, doesn't apologize to be overanalytical or intellectual, it is not constantly obsessed with spoilers, it is aware of bad distribution and political problematics of the industry, it knows what an independent film is, it does not fear controversial debates, it does speak of mise en scène and form.

The accessibility of foreign films on the French market (the big screen, and not just in Paris) is way better than anywhere in America, even in NYC. Well, you read in the French press more inquisitive articles on the weakness of the distribution, on blind spots, on favouritism, on bad management of our state subsidies, on the complacency of the industry, on the Hollywood ubiquity, on perverse marketing tactics... When there isn't enough Hollywood films in Cannes, or no comedy genre represented in the selection for years, the French press talks about it, and confront the status quo openly. We can read both sides of the issue expressed in the articles, on the radio, on TV. It is not taboo to put into question the "Exception française", to compare our market failures to Hollywood's market...
However, in America, the state of theatrical distribution is infinitely worse, and instead of making the press angrier... American critics don't give a fuck, don't talk about it, don't even see it as a problem for the balance of world cinema!!! What exactly do you think French criticism needs to learn from reading the American press, translated or not??? Do French critics need a masterclass in populist pandering, in demagoguery, in puritan hypocrisy?

I'm all for cultural exchanges, so translation of foreign press should be more widespread, by principle. Even if the content sucks.
But honestly, if you've read anything in the French press (and I don't like everything, by a large margin, even most of what Cahiers and Positif do), you'd realise that French critics are probably more self-critical about French criticism, about French cinema, about the French industry than any other critics. They are also sometimes more insightful about American movies than American critics themselves! (History proved that time and again)
What would American critics would have to say about the French press, the French industry, the French market... when all they know about France is what is marketed to them by Hollywood publicits! Even when they go to Cannes, all they care about is to trash independent East-European movies because they aren't as glossy and light-hearted as a Hollywood flick.

We obviously have a lot to learn from eachothers, but not from the current cultural environment. Maybe after the language barrier and the cultural policies become more permeable, after a few years or decades of mutual exchanges... then there'll be some substance to share.

It's not all bad in the American press, and not always bad... but the standards consistency isn't high enough on average. Influenced by the decline of journalistic standards on TV, there is no minimal level of sound arguments in film discourse... every pundit believes they can say whatever they want on anything, and they even get published by the high-profile press. In France, the profile of the publication usually corresponds to the level of quality we can expect from their content. Do you really think the NYT, or the various cinephile specialized publications live up to the quality we'd expect from them? (I have a few examples if you can't think of any)
The confrontation of American and French press will not flatter American writers... let's put it that way. So I'm not sure it is a clever move to turn the "isolationism issue" back in our face (especially since the question asked by the host was about the relevance of French cinema, not French criticism!). I would bet that, as little as the average French critic knows about the American film press, it still is more than what American critics know about the French film press themselves, or anything about French culture at all... And France is probably one of the countries they would more likely know something about, outside of the UK. What do they know about Italy, Portugal, Romania, Iran, Korea...?

What's tragic is that within this cultural isolationism, there is usually a small underground pocket of resistants who defy the dominant attitude and think outside the box, a group of activists who seek out knowledge that is not available in their country through the official channels, bypassing the censorship, cultural barriers and national-centric interests, moved by a love for global cinema beyond any borders. If there was a dozen Jonathan Rosenbaum in the American film press, I think it would have come to my attention by now, even as ignorant as I am of American culture. And there should be. Owning a DVD collection of a few French films doesn't make a film reviewer an anti-isolationism activist. I don't see this cultural resistance anywhere, I don't preceive on the internet the indirect shockwaves of its presence, I don't see the results of its secret achievements.

Back to the French Critics Legacy theme: when this pocket of resistance existed in France, during WW2 and afterwards, we could see the cultural impact and we still are grateful today for the services they rendered for world cinema culture, by saving silent film prints and not only French films! (Langlois), by developping a network of cine-clubs to educate the public at large (Bazin), by supporting foreign films not visible in France (Rissient), by nurturing a cinephile press (Cahiers, Positif)...
France is a much smaller country that the USA, with a much smaller economy, a much smaller movie business, a much smaller audience, and language much less widespread than English... So logically, anything similar happening within the USA should be remarkably more visible. Where is it? What American (so-called) cinephiles fight for? What do they support? What is their ambition for American culture? Do they care what the MPAA does to cinema industries in other countries?
What is left from the Sarris-Kael legacy for today's American cinephiles to work on? They can now use snob words such as "Nouvelle Vague", "mise en scene", "montage", "cinephile" to impress their friends... but apart from that?
They aren't helping foreign filmmakers get screened, or get better exposed. They aren't making the film press substance any deeper. They aren't producing a new generation of filmmakers more aware of world cinema. They aren't teaching in film schools life-changing classes. They aren't taking serious criticism to the radio or TV.

Mekas' Film-makers Cooperative is expelled to the street of NYC, the most cinephile-friendly city in the USA. The LACMA film program, in the city of the world's richest movie industry, is shut down. When screenwriters and actors protest in the street, it's not like Truffaut and Godard in 1967 to save Langlois' Cinémathèque, or to take down the studios stronghold, or to give copyrights and director's cut to the auteur of the film... you know, noble, selfless, ethical issues... no, they march the street to get more money for themselves! This doesn't look like a country who cares for cinema as an art detached from personal/national/corporate interests... It's not surprising that the industry, the government or even the institutions don't care about this. But that's when there should be a pocket of resistance against the mainstream opinion, who actively defends these cultural principles. And even if it's an unattainable goal in practicality, it shouldn't stop anybody from TALKING ABOUT IT again and again. Making it part of the film discourse doesn't cost a dime. And since USA is a democracy, it doesn't even take the courage of Iranian or Syrian filmmakers, to risk imprisonment for speaking up... Yet American cinephiles freely choose not to be activist and disregard the basic rights cultural diversity should enjoy on the American market... clinging to the comfort of their own DVD collections (half of which was pirated online, which doesn't even support the way of life of foreign filmmakers). It just shows American cinephiles don't care as badly about the place of cinema in their culture as French cinéphiles did back in the days...

If you don't do it "to do like France did", or for world culture... at least be selfish and do it for yourself, do it for the future generations of American movie consumers, do it for the level of culture a country like yours deserves and should aspire to. You don't have to compare USA to France and its "cultural exception"... but you should at least attain a decent cultural development for yourself. And isolationism is not acceptable, not for Iran or China, less so for USA : leader of the "free" world.


I wonder how many more decades and generations it will take for American culture to be as open to the outside world as their patronizing political talking points suggest it is. I'll keep repeating myself until I see some changes. And so should you.


"[..] I don't want to rain on his Parade [..] I don't want to criticize an excellent book I came away from whistling the theme from Mon Oncle. Just like in Tati's film, it is the play between the old world and the new that makes Goodbye Cinema, Hello Cinephilia so valuable and unique."
A.S. Hamrah, review of Rosenbaum's Goodbye Cinema, Hello Cinephilia, 2011 (Cineaste, Spring 2011)
When his book is reviewed by a friendly admirer in a magazine where he's listed as an associate... there is not much critical insight to expect indeed. All Hamrah did was recounting how he watched the movies cited in Rosenbaum's book... ME ME ME. That's the American style of journalism. Always make the reader relate to a pointless subjective anecdote.
I would hope that Rosenbaum's retirement would give him the time necessary to write proper books. An anthology of already-published articles is for others to publish after your death... Just like I wish he would be a little bit more vocal about American culture and American cinema on his blog, instead of posting old articles that are available elsewhere. Again, this is the job for an archivist. A serious critic should dedicate his time to write new material, which mere archivists cannot do for him. If he writes a book on Dreyer or Godard... I will probably not like it, but at least he would do his job of film writer, and contribute to expand Film discourse in these areas, which will make wannabe reviewers who look up to him, hopefully smarter.


Anyway this radio interview is very interesting, and the content of Rosenbaum's speech changes a lot from what we generaly hear about American culture, about world culture as seen by Americans, about niche markets, cine-clubs... in the American press. So listen to it and pass it around, because this type of discourse should become the dominant discourse, at least within cinephilia, if not mainstream media. If more American "cinephiles" would think that way, and make a point of spreading this mentality everywhere they can, in their articles, to their friends, or at their cine-clubs... this would start to make constructive evolution in the  isolationist brainwashing, time allowing.

    Related: 

    Fonction d'un festival (Boyer)


    Entretien avec Frédéric Boyer (Quinzaine des Réalisateurs)
    27 avril 2011 (forumdesimages) 14'53"

    Voir aussi:

    23 avril 2011

    MPAA not interested in democratized culture

    "If you do not believe in the value of creativity, the importance of protecting it and the need to reward those who produce, then maybe you can justify piracy. But in that case you’ll be doing great harm to culture. [..] Obviously, governments and societies have to work to make sure that the population has access to the basics in order to survive, but that does not mean you should ignore other things. Companies must live together because they respect each other and respect that people do not steal from one another. Even if you battle to put food on your plate, it is immoral to steal [..] [Creative Commons supporters] don’t always agree with what we advocate. And you are talking about democratizing culture, this is not in our interests. It really isn’t my interest."
    Greg Frazier (MPAA Vice President) during a lobbying visit to Brazil 
    The MPAA is merely protecting their corporate interests. [..]
    To the MPAA and many others in the entertainment industry, copyright has little to do with the word right, nor with creativity and culture. Instead, it’s a restrictive tool that allows works to be traded, leased and licensed in return for money.
    Indeed, democratizing culture is not in the MPAA’s interest, but maximizing profits and control is.
    Ernesto (Torrentfreak, 20 april 2011) 

    Let's put this into perspective (figures for 2009) :

    USA Brazil
    GDP (purchasing power parity) $ 14.7 trillion $ 2.2 trillion 
    GDP per capita $ 47,400 $ 10,900 
    Cinema BO (total) billion $ 29.4  0.481 
    Cinema BO (domestic share) % 91.8% 14.3%

    I don't have the exact figure detailing the foreign films imports in Brazil, but I wouldn't be surprised if Hollywood owned about 90 to 99% of the non domestic share. In any case Hollywood already earns more money (80-85% of 481 = $385 million) from Brazilian consumers than the Brazilian filmmakers/producers (14.3% = $96 million). Any non-American film industry would be overjoyed with such figures... but the MPAA is greedier than this. They won't be happy until Brazilians spend all their money in legal sales or in lawsuit fines, instead of paying their bills or investing in their own domestic culture... That's sad. When you're number 1 in the world, by a large margin, you are expected to show a bit of modesty and compassion for those who couldn't even dream of reaching the level of benefits you make every year in legal sales, and no be so damn ruthless about the few unsignificant peanuts left on the floor after your industrial harvest!!! Peanuts that matter little to your overall commercial balance, and are primordial to the survival of the foreign market you cream out. Nah, the cultural business is not about diversity, exchange and support... the MPAA sees foreign art as COMPETITION. 

    In the USA, cinema is not an art, it is a competitive commerce, and crushing competitors is the only goal.

    And since America deals with world cinema like any of its foreign policy : meaning as a marketing strategy, they abuse of their political leverage and economical incentive to subdue weaker economical competitors to the laws established by their hegemony. Might is right. And mighty will get mightier.
    America is already lucky that the entire world (barred a few rebellious countries like Iran or North Korea) spontaneously loves Hollywood movies, in any honest blind test (the mainstream crowd at least). People prefer Hollywood movies over their own domestic filmmakers, even in countries where the cinema industry has the capability to compete on equal footing (quality wise). That is a market winner right there, without any effort. But that's not enough, they want to use marketing brainwashing, domestic culture attrition, quotas ban, economic pressures... If they were number 2 desperately trying to snatch the number 1 rank, that would be a greedy mentality. But since their total domination of the market is not threatened to be overtaken any time soon... this attitude really lacks class, not to mention morality.

    They are just jealous of the tax-free revenue the black market generates. But the consumers of the black market do not belong to them, even the police cannot turn 100% of black market consumers into legal consumers, because either they cannot afford legla prices, or because if it wasn't free/really cheap, they would not buy at all. Fighting the black market, which is sometimes the only access to a wide culture (against government censorship), will never increase dramatically the market share of legal sales.

    Still, they want to lecture Brazilians about the morality of copyrights. Ironically, at home they don't even respect copyrights themselves! They make everything legally possible to contain foreign film distribution under 10% on their own market, just to make the Hollywood remakes more profitable! Which is exactly the equivalent of installing an unofficial quota of 98% for their domestic market. It's not the American audience who doesn't want to watch foreign films, or that foreign films are not as good as Hollywood... it's that the American distribution market is not giving foreign films a fair chance to meet an audience! Yet the MPAA complains about countries such as France, Korea or Brazil who try to keep the Hollywood films under 50% with official quotas. What hypocrisy!!!
    They don't care about copyrights, because screenwriters (actual owners of artistic property rights!) and actors have to march in the street to get a decent share of the profits made by producers!!!

    The legal way is not always the best way to look at the situation. Maybe it sounds absurd to suggest such a thing... but I thought America was founded on principles like overriding an unjust law.
    Copyrights laws existed for concrete goods sold from hand to hand. It is impossible to apply them to the radical transformation of the global market and its virtual goods and its invisible consumers.

    All the MPAA cares about is to maximize profits for their investors. It is a business operation. It has nothing to do with defending copyrights against piracy, or supporting their screenwriters, or defending art, or claiming moral high ground with emphatic discourses!


    Related:

    20 avril 2011

    L'homme à la caméra (Pourvali)


    Cours de cinéma de Bamchade Pourvali : L'homme à la caméra de Dziga Vertov
    8 avril  2011 (forumdesimages) 1h17'

    18 avril 2011

    Critical Fallacy 12 : Spoiler alerts

    THIS IS A SPOILER ALERT, BE WARNED : If you are afraid that words might steal your virginity, close your eyes and stick your head in the sand before reading any further. Don't watch trailers, don't listen to P.R. talking points, don't watch actors' TV promotional tour, don't read newspapers and reviews, don't read synopsis and ratings, don't read film criticism or film studies, don't go to film school. And if you like biopics, documentaries and movies based on a true story : do not watch the news, ever.
    Host: "My own opinion about spoilers has long been that if a film is actually spoiled by revealing plot details what you have is a bad film. Can I take you to agree with that? [..] What do you think about the notion that the second time you watch a movie is actually the first time because you're not preoccupied by following the story?"
    Jonathan Rosenbaum interview (The Marketplace of Ideas, 20 Feb 2011) 57'34" [MP3]
    Rosenbaum demonstrates an incredible patience and politeness facing the deplorable questions of this affected radio host!
    The anti-spoiler has nothing to do with the intrinsic quality of films themselves (any Hitchcock; Citizen Kane; M; 2001: A Space Odyssey; Stalker; The Exterminating Angel; La Jetée; Blow-up; The Taste of Cherry... are not "bad films"), but with the restrictions imposed on film writing liberty. And film criticism is not exclusive to pre-screening reviewing (where we kinda expect the plot synopsis to respect the surprise for the virgin spectators). Like Rosenbaum says, if we can re-watch a film over and over, knowing the plot by heart, without feeling cheated, we can also read another kind of film writing that doesn't focus on superficial pre-screening recommendations : serious filmic criticism (wherein some spoilers are inevitable).
    Spoiler (see: Wikipedia) :  Any element of any summary or description of any piece of fiction that reveals any plot element which will give away the outcome of a dramatic episode within the work of fiction, or the conclusion of the entire work.
    A spoiler reveals the story, but doesn't ruin a film for ever! It is possible to rewatch a film and enjoy it, even knowing what happens. Knowing classic stories, their main arcs, their premise and conclusions, and being able to talk about them, to make references, to produce parody or homages... is what constitutes general culture generations after generations. It's not the mysteries of top-secret plots that consolidate society around a common culture.
    "Some people’s obsessive preoccupation with spoilers has been driving me batty lately. It isn’t only among moviegoers; many fiction readers are equally afflicted. [..] Give me a break. Is this form of worry a fit activity for grown-ups? [..] The weird metaphysical implication of spoilers is that moviegoers and readers who fret about them want to regain their innocence, perhaps maybe even their infancy, and experience everything as if it were absolutely fresh. From this standpoint, we shouldn’t even know what films we’re going to see in advance, or who stars in them, or who directed them, or what they’re about, or perhaps even where they’re playing. Just so we can experience the bliss of being taken there by benevolent parents."
    In defense of spoilers, Jonathan Rosenbaum, Chicago Reader, 2006

    Movie spoilers and Spoiler movies

    It is obviously the movie industry that has implanted this irrational fear of spoilers in the mind of the mass audience... because it helps to boost their sales. Indeed, curiosity killed the cat. Or more trivially, if you warn the mouse about the violent slap after that delicious bite into the piece of cheese, you'll never catch a mouse. In other words, a spectator who has minimal information about a film, might be tempted to buy a ticket anyway, out of curiosity : inflating box office numbers with an audience that would not have watched it if they knew it didn't correspond to their taste.

    If the film is bad, it's better to shut up the reviewers as much as possible, so that readers won't believe mere opinions, legally deprived of backed up evidences. More consumers paying before being disappointed! The take-the-money-and-run type of first weekend marketing strategy.
    If the film is good, the whole mystery sustained by actors, marketing campaign, reviewers and the spectators who have already seen it, who only spread the buzz with subtle spoiler-free ellipses and circumnavigations, will inevitably push more curious spectators to buy a ticket, to know what it's all about, to be part in turn of this secret community of "people who can speak freely about spoilers amongst themselves". Even if in the end, the film wasn't worth all the extrapolated fantasy that mystery alone generates because the imagination runs wild (most often favourably) when we can't put definitive words on actual things. Again, more consumers than what the film would attract by itself (without the mystery marketing tactic).

    Ironically, the movie industry doesn't see any problems with selling a movie on DVD that everyone has already seen in theatres... Not only the plot and ending is spoiled for this potential consumer demographic, but the ENTIRE film too, yet they sell us completely spoiled meat, without any precautions or remorse. Double standards! Same with re-runs on TV, it is not perceived as a waste of air time and money even if "spoiled movies" allegedly do not attract audience.

    This is bullshit. Responsible spectators are able to figure out whether a 5 lines synopsis, or a 5 pages analysis may or may not spoil an entire film. The film pages of a newspaper or a blog are probably the easiest things to avoid if you worry about being spoiled. Water-cooler conversations, eavesdropping, TV shows... might catch you off guard, and you only figure out that you didn't want to hear that when it's too late. 


    Now about the legitimacy of spoiler-prohibition, in particular cases.

    Reviewers ought to be responsible too. Obviously, if you're only writing a capsule review, it is not worth spoiling anything in the film, just stick to generalities and elements that won't put the potential spectator ahead of the film, instead of being dragged along by the suspension of disbelief. First, because this kind of pithy comments are designed solely for readers who haven't seen the film yet. Secondly because readers who will not go watch that film, will find even less interest in the revelation of these spoilers. Thirdly because you have to deserve the privilege to cite a sensitive plot element, by dedicating time and words to the utilization of these unfortunate spoilers.
    A writer must not spoil gratuitously, out of pure perversion : I know something you don't know, and I will rub it in your face to make myself look good. (see: 100 Movie Spoilers in 5 minutes) That is pointless and stupid.  Yet we see that going on with a lot of reviews. Writers who reject the anti-spoiler policy, and just list spoiler after spoiler to show off, without making any productive use out of it. This is irresponsible. If you do not need a certain spoiler to make any worthwhile point at all, just stay away from spoilers.

    Also, before resorting to spoilers, you should always make sure it is otherwise impossible to use cunning phrasing that will spare the virgin readers, while hinting at a very precise detail that only someone who has seen the film would understand. This is part of the literary skills required to be a good reviewer! And it is not that hard to use ambiguous words, or only implicit half-truths that do not reveal anything specific explicitly, thus saving the mystery for the future audience.

    If you must reveal something that might pre-condition the reader into expecting something along the plot, or put them in an anxious wait for a detailed scene (which trailers do all the time), then it is really going to alter the spontaneous responsiveness of these readers during the film. The wording of your article, or even it's paragraph structure should unmistakably announce the cursory analysis incoming. You don't have to spell out "spoiler alert" either, this is very infantilizing (like Rosenbaum says). Just show a little bit of curtsy and do not start a sentence with a spoiler coming out of nowhere, without the reader being able to realize it is going to happen.

    Related: